J.J's POV
"Where did Katherine go?" I asked.
"Didn't she say she went to go get her bag downstairs?" Juliet asked sounding confused.
"That was twenty minutes ago." I said grabbing my gun. "I'll be back."
I slowly walked down the stairs, both hands on my gun.
"Katherine?" I called out.
No answer.
I walked through the living room, making sure it was clear, and walked into the kitchen where there was a small pool of blood.
Katherine was no where to be found. I took out my phone and called Hotch.
"Hey Hotch. We have a problem." I said. Spence was going to kill me.
Katherine's POV
I woke up with a pounding headache in a dark room.
"You're up." Michael said. I could hardly make out his figure sitting across from me in a chair.
"Where am I?" I asked slowly inching away from him. He turned on a light and I immediately recognized the room.
We were in his grandmothers house.
"I knew you would know where we are." He said.
"Why are you doing this, Michael?" I asked.
"Because I love you!" He said climbing on the bed. "They hurt you and I needed to protect you!"
"The people you killed didn't hurt me." I said inching away from him more.
"No, but they stood in the way of me getting what I want." He said grabbing my hands. "I always get what I want."
"W-what did you do the ones you didn't kill?" I stuttered.
"Who says I didn't kill them? The most fun was Derek." He said grinning. "He sure put up a fight."
My jaw dropped.
"You sick son of a bitch! You're going to pay for this! They're going to find you and you're going to go to jail forever!" I yelled.
"Who's going to catch me? That geeky little FBI agent of yours? Who says he isn't next?" He asked.
"You son of a bitch! I swear if you touch him you're going to pay!" I yelled. He laughed and walked out of the room.
Spencer's POV
"Hey guys." I said putting my bag down next to the chair I was just about to sit in. They all just looked at me. "Is something wrong?"
"Spencer," Hotch started out. He never called me Spencer unless it was serious. "Katherine was taken from Detective O'Hara's house last night."
"You're joking, right?" I asked not knowing what to say. They all just stared at me. "Hotch, I swear if this is some kind of sick joke-"
"I'm not joking, Reid." Hotch said.
"This is all my fault." J.J said standing up.
"No it's not, J.J." Rossi said.
"It's all of our faults. We were supposed to be watching her. One of us should've gone downstairs with her." Emily said.
"It's none of your faults. This sick son of a bitch killed almost 10 people and took Katherine. This is his fault. Not ours. Not hers." Morgan said.
"And we'll do everything in our power to get her back." Hotch said.
"We found finger prints in the kitchen." Detective O'Hara said walking into the conference room. "They belong to Michael Prescott."
"Morgan you and Detective Lassiter go back to the fraternity house and see if any of the students know where he went. J.J you and Prentiss go back to his parents house to ask the same. Rossi you and I will go back to the crime scene. Reid you stay here with Detective O'Hara." Hotch said.
"I can't just sit here, Hotch. I need to be out there looking for Kate." I argued.
"What's going to help us most right now is if you stay here and help Garcia. As of now you know Katherine better than any of us." He said.
"Hotch, I don't think he's working alone." Rossi said as the others left.
"Me either. Reid you work with Garcia to find out more about Katherine's background." Hotch said.
"Sure thing, Hotch." I said. Hotch and Rossi left and Detective O'Hara went to go to talk to Chief Vick.
"Hello my lovely." Penelope said popping up onto the monitor.
"Hey Penelope, I take it you heard." I said sadly.
"Yeah, sorry kiddo. I know how much you liked her." She said.
"You make it sound like she's never coming back." I said chuckling slightly.
"I'm sorry, Reid. I just feel really bad because I was right there but not really and she got taken without any of us knowing." She said.
"Garcia, it's not your fault. If anything it's my fault. I should've been there with her instead of at a hotel." I said.
"It was girl's night." She said.
"Yeah well look where that got us." I said. She looked down. "Sorry, anyway. We need your computer skills."
"Garcia at your service. Your wish is my command. What do you need pretty boy?"
"Well Hotch wants us to dig into Kate's background. Can you find any school activities she was in the last 8 years?"
"You two have nicknames for each other already? What does she call you?" She asked with a smirk.
"Garcia!" I said.
"Sorry I'm on it."
"Thanks."
"Wow."
"What?"
"She was quite the remarkable teenager. She was in 7 different clubs, captain of 4 sports and volunteered at the Center for Enriched Living which is a living area for disabled people."
"What clubs and sports teams were she involved with?"
"She was a part of Literary Journal, GSA, Honors Society, Gamers Club, Latin Dance, Adventure Ed, and Student Leader's. She was captain of the volleyball, softball, soccer, and basketball team. She had a 4.6 GPA and had an IQ of 185. She's almost as smart as you are."
I rolled my eyes.
"Can you cross reference the names of the clubs and sports teams to see if any particular person were in more than three?"
"For a smart person you sure do ask stupid questions. There were two people who were in all the same clubs and went to UCLA with her. This isn't good."
"What? Garcia tell me."
"Michael Prescott and Jessica Tyler."
"Can you get me Jessica's address?"
"Yeah she lives on 5275 N. Kennicot. She lives with her parents James Tyler and Lily Tyler."
"Thanks Garcia. She calls me Spence by the way."
She grinned before disappearing. I took out my phone and called Hotch.
"Hey Hotch. We got a lead. We think that Jessica Tyler is working with Michael. She lives at 5275 N. Kennicot with her parents James and Lily Tyler." I said.
"What's your reason?" Hotch asked.
"She was in all the same clubs as her and Michael and she was co-coach of her sports teams." I said.
"Thanks Reid. Rossi and I are heading over there now." He said.
Hotch's POV
"They got a lead." I said putting my phone away.
"Where are we heading?" Rossi asked.
"5275 N. Kennicot. Only a couple blocks away from here."
"What's the story?"
"Jessica Tyler lives with her parents. She and Michael were in all the same clubs as Katherine and Jessica was co-captain to Katherine's captain."
"Are we thinking jealousy lead to helping him commit the murders to hurt Katherine?"
"That's what I'm thinking. We won't know until we find out." I said as Rossi pulled down Kennicot.
Song of the Chapter: Save You Tonight by One Direction
A/N Hey guys, so I just made an Instagram like an hour ago so you should follow me and on Twitter too!
Instagram- cassie_oliva
Twitter- @cassie_oliva
Thanks guys <3