Toby's pov
I didn't mean to do that to (y/n). I was only trying to protect her from Casey, but I ended up hurting her more than Casey ever could.
We were only about a quarter mile from the portal when I stopped again. Casey turned around and glared at me. "Hurry up Toby, Mr.Creepypasta will kill us!" she screeched. "I'm not going with you" I mumbled. "I love (y/n), not you I shouldn't have done this.". She stood there shocked."We had a deal, you love me and I'll leave (y/n) alone, because I Can make her life a living nightmare!"she yelled. I was filled with anger, how dare she threaten my one and only true love!!!
"If you go near her I will rip your fucking head off you skank!"I shouted. I was just as surprise as she was. I never cussed and I always kept my cool. But her threatening (y/n) made me so mad.
I turned around and started running back to the mansion, I looked back to see a tear fall off Casey's cheek before she began running towards the portal again. I hope (y/n) will forgive me, I thought as I ran faster.
your pov
I hate my life, I thought as I floated in the darkness.Am I dead, I should have woken up by now. Did the bracelet not work? Suddenly I sat up. I was in slendermans office."Why am I still here! " I shouted. "(y/n) I'm sorry, I really am." Said a familiar voice. I turned around and saw Toby there. With no one else in the room I could attack him......but I did miss him so I'll listen. For now."You have three minutes to explain."I said sternly.
"Okay well...."
~forty minutes later~
"So you were with her to protect me?"I asked. "She was going to hurt you, I couldn't let her do that. " Toby said. I was so relieved that he still loved me, I thought I had lost him!"I love you Toby! " I cried out jumping into his arms. He bear hugged me. I kissed him on the lips and nuzzled into his neck. "Don't you ever leave me again!"I said."And by the way, how did I get back here?" "Oh that," He said smiling "Slenderman teleported there and brought you back before you woke up." "(Y/n) come with me real quick,"he said.He grabbed my hand and dragged me down stairs. I didn't see anyone and usually the house was full of the loud pastas running around. He pulled me onto the back patio. On the patio was a table with two chairs and on it was (your favourite food). Toby quickly pulled me aside. "I forgot something, very important"he said. He went inside real quick and brought out a beautiful (favourite color) dress and black high heels. "Toby! This is amazing, you didnt have to didn't all this for me!"I said. "Well Masky cooked the desert and slendy cooked the meal, but the rest was me. "he said. I took the dress and ran to the nearest room to change. After I got out I saw Toby waiting outside the door in a tux. He looked absolutely adorable. He hooked his arm in mine and lead me back out side. He sat me back down in my chair then looked at me. "Silly me I forgot the most important detail" he said. And with that he got down on one knee and took out a small velvet box. He opened it and inside was a ring with black diamonds all the way around it and a big bright one in the middle. "(y/n) will you make me the happiest creepypasta on earth and be mine forever?" He said.I squealed and hugged him, he lost his balance and I fell onto of him."I'll take that as a yes,"he said chuckling. "Yes, yes!"I shouted."I love you so much Toby!" I was crying with joy. He picked me up and sat on my chair pulling me onto his lap. We feed each other food and and laughed all evening.
After diner he brought me inside and sat me on the couch. He walked over to the TV and put on (your fav. movie) and sat next to me. I hugged him and cuddled up next to him.
Toby's pov
(y/n) is so beautiful. She finally fell asleep. I looked down to see (y/n) lightly snoring while hugging my side. I chuckled and picked her up bridal style. I carried her to my room and set her on the bed. I put her pajamas next to her in case she wakes up. I grabbed my pajamas and went to the restroom to change.
When I came back (y/n) was sitting up on the bed in her pajamas. I went over to her and hugged her. She pulled me onto the bed and yawned. I snaked my arms around her waist pulling her closer to me and shut my eyes.
