It's Not What It Looks Like!

50 4 1
                                        

Last time on "Autumn Finds Something New"

Toby: I just noticed something

Autumn: What's that?

Toby: Your eyes glow red when you change form

Autumn: I know. I hate it.

Toby: I don't. It makes you look even prettier

At that moment someone walks in.

Back to the story

Jasmine, Casada, Jennifer, and Brandi walk in. I'm pretty sure they saw Toby on top of me like something happened because their jaws dropped. I look at Toby then at my friends then at Toby then my friends.

Autumn: It's not what it looks like!

Brandi: Wow, I didn't think you moved on so fast

Autumn: No, I haven't. Not exactly

Jennifer: Aw, you still have fellings for Oliver <3

Toby was off of me at this point so I went up to Jennifer and punched her in the stomach.

Jennifer: Oww!

Autumn: That's what you get for saying I still have feelings for that duche bag.

Jennifer fell to the floor. I knelt over her with my hand raised about  to slap her. The next thing I know Masky walks in. I lowered my hand. I'm pretty sure he saw me knelt over top of Jen like something happened once again.

Autumn: It's not what it looks like!

Masky: Whoa, didn't know you were bi.

Autumn: I'm not bi.

Masky: You say it so calmly. How am I supposed to believe you?

I push Masky into the wall and take my knife and put it to his throat. I whisper to him softly but still had an angered tone.

Autumn: I'm Not Bi.

Next thing you know Slendy walks in. His jaw dropped. I back away as quickly as possible. 

Autumn: Slendy it's not what it looks like!

Slenderman: I know what I saw. I can't believe you would do something like this!

I calmly tell him all that happened and why I put my knife to his throat.

Slenderman: *sighs* So he was acting like a total butthole then?

Autumn: Yeah.

Slenderman: Understood. Sorry for my temper. 

He bowed and walked out dragging Masky along. My friends let themselves out. Leaving me and Toby alone once again.

Autumn Finds Someone New (Ticci Toby Romance)Where stories live. Discover now