Brother or Lover - Caleb x reader

Part 1

A couple weeks after moving in together, you decide that you and Caleb should go on a proper date now that you two are official. It was simple day—walking by the beach, splashing the water onto each other, reminiscing your childhood times, then trying out a new cafe just by the roadside. Everything is perfect, and it felt like a dream. You cling on his arm, gleeful and relaxed as he tells you the tales of your childhood while you both walk to the cafe.

"Y/n? Is that you?" You feel a pat on your shoulder as the voice calls to you. You turn around squinting your eyes at the person, jogging your memory a bit until a moment of clarity strikes.

"Oh it's you! I haven't see you in a long time, I missed you so much!" You let go of Caleb's arm, pulling your old friend into your arms. You both squeal excitedly, exchanging greetings and compliments, and for a second you forgot that you were on a date with Caleb.

"Who's that?" Your friend gestures at him after you both calm down a little.

"I'm their bo-"

"Brother! He's my brother!" You cut Caleb's words off before he could finish it. Caleb tilts his head slightly as he looks at you, wearing an expression of annoyance and confusion. When his gaze meets your eyes and he sees the sparkle of mischief in them he decides to play along.

"Right... I'm their brother. Nice to meet you, y/n's friend." He plasters a fake smile, jaws clenched as the word brother passes through his mouth. Thankfully your friend didnt notice this and pay their attention back to you.

"Oh we have so much to catch up! How've you been these days? How's life? Seeing anyone?" Their eyebrow quirks up as they flash a cheeky smile with the last question. "Let's find us a table, and if he doesnt mind he can join us too."

Time sure flies fast when you have so much to talk about with your old friend, and it was already late evening when you parted ways with them. You cling on your lover's arm, tugging on his sleeve as you both walk towards his car.

"They sure are lively huh?" You smile as you try to meet his gaze. Silence. His face is stoic and he didnt even look at you back. He just opens the passenger door, waits for you to come in, closes the door and takes his place at the driver's seat. It might be too late to realize now, but come to think of it he was awfully quiet during the whole time you guys were at the cafe.

He just keeps on driving in eerie silence, eyes glued to the road and unresponsive to any attempts of you lighten his mood up. He grips on the steering wheel as if he could crumple it into scrape metal. 'Is it because of the brother thing? I was just joking because they dont know about him.' You thought to yourself.

You finally reach home and he opens the door for you. You gather your courage in a breath and open your mouth "Caleb, I'm so-"

"Brother, huh?" He slams the door behind you. "I thought we already move pass that."

He steps closer and closer invading your personal space. His towering frame trapping your body against the door.

"Wait, Caleb! I didnt mean-"

"Shut it."

You pressed your lips together, not allowing any sound coming through anymore.

"Brother." He scoffs. Then his face inching closer to yours and he slams his lips on yours.

"What kind of brother I'd be-" A kiss. "...desiring for his little sister like this?" Another kiss. "What kind of brother-" Kiss. "...would dreaming of undressing his little sister day in and day out?" Kiss. "Tell me, y/n, would a big brother touches his little sister like this?" Kiss, kiss, more deeper kisses.

You try to shove him away, fighting for your life as he keep stealing your breath quite literally again and again. "Caleb, please, I need to breathe..."

"Shush sister, didnt grandmother teach you not to interrupt your brother when he's talking?" He brushes his lips lightly along your neck, his warm breath fanning over your skin. You let out a whimper as they finally made contact with your skin and it felt as if lightning rushes through your body.

"Caleb..."

He plants more kisses along your neck as his hands work on the buttons of your blouse. He parts your blouse halfway, exposing your upper body. One of his big rough hands cupping one of your breasts as the other rests on your hips. He greedily kisses your exposed skin over and over, making sure no spot left untouched. Neck, collarbones, shoulders. Then he moves lower. Chest, waist, stomach until he's now down on his knees.

He is sensual yet possessive. He's savouring the moans that erupted from your mouth but he's making sure his touch is slow and delibrate so he knows only he can turn you into a mess. Now his hands making their way under your skirt, lifting the fabric up until your crotch is exposed. His eyes hooked on the wet spot on your panties.

"You're practically dripping, y/n." He smirks."Is it because how badly you need to be touched here...." He runs a finger along your slit over the damp panties and you shiver, almost falling to your knees. "Or are you getting turned on that your brother is doing this to you?"

"Caleb, mmmmhhh..." you melt as he shove his face into your crotch. He hooks your legs over his shoulders for better access and purposely drag his tongue slow and along your pussy. He'd push his tongue on the spot where your entrance would be and drag it to your clit, flicking his tongue until he could feel you shudder and repeat the process again and again.

"Hahh... Ahhh... Ca- Caleb! That feels... It feels good!!! Ah!"

He latches his mouth on your clit and starts sucking it. You look down and your eyes were met with his dark, lustful gaze. His fingers digging into your thighs leaving no chance for you to escape. Whenever his lips leave your throbbing bud, his tongue will come replace the absence. Whenever his mouth meets your mound again he'd hum and groan, sending vibration to your core.

"Oh my god, I'm close! I need to c-cum! Please, Caleb! Mmmmm- A-aaaahh!"

"Answer one simple question first." He lifts his face. His mouth parted away ever so slightly from your folds and it's already making you miss his oppressive warmness.

"What am I to you?"