A light chuckle brings you back to reality, your neck snapping back up to meet his gaze, a lazy smile on his lips. He'd caught you ogling. Shit. It doesn't matter, you tell yourself; you've done worse with him than this innocent stare. He's gorgeous — he knows it, you know it, you could be adults about it. Even after your heated make out session.
You snatch the cereal box back from him and he takes a few steps back, leaning against the counter to watch you search for a bowl, a spoon, and some milk. Clattering around, you huff, finally locating everything you needed after a bit of fuss. It would be easier if this Adonis wasn't watching your every move.
"Don't you have anywhere else to be? Like, up in the sky?" you press, scooting him over with a flick of your wrist so you can assemble your breakfast.
He shakes his head. "Training's been canceled. Bad weather." Hangman walks around the counter and settles into one of barstools directly across from you. His green eyes bore into you, his smile still ever present, the sickening combination sending your heart racing. You do your best to ignore it and lift a spoonful of cereal to your lips, chomping on it harshly to distract yourself, forcing yourself to look away from him.
"So is the mood because you're hangry or have you been left unsatisfied another night?" His lips curl around the word as he probes with his question, his eyes dropping to your sweatshirt.
"Why do you care?" you ask, shifting your weight from one foot to the other, settling into your right hip.
"Well, your mood is either going to improve in just a few minutes here," he tips his head in the direction of your cereal bowl. "Or I'm going to have to offer my services and take matters into my own hands."
Your choke on the milk in your mouth, shocked but not surprised at his forwardness. Swallowing, you meet his gaze and shake your head. "Why? Have you run through every other viable option here or what?"
He chuckles, reaching up to scratch his cheek. "I always have options, sweetheart. I just know you were having a good time with me the other night, I thought you might like to keep it going." He raises an eyebrow, taking his lip between his teeth. God, he was relentless.
You groan, rolling your eyes. "Do you have an off button, Jake?" you mumble between bites.
His eyes light up, widening as his name falls from your lips. His smile shifts, lifting on the right, a smug cockiness settling in as he chews his bottom lip, his eyebrow raised. "So you do remember," he winks.
His arrogance is almost too much to bear, his confidence boost palpable. He shifts in his chair, straightening up, flexing every muscle of his abdomen. You roll your eyes and turn away from him, placing your cereal bowl in the sink. He hums quietly, drumming his fingers against the countertop, awaiting a response.
You sigh. "Yes, fine, I remember."
"I knew you wouldn't be able to forget. No one can." He lifts his knuckles to his lips, blowing on them and rubbing them against his chest. Cocky son of a bitch.
"Whatever, Hangman." You walk out of the small kitchenette and cross the room to the couch, plopping down on the leather.
"Come on, I told you to call me Jake." He spins around in the barstool, his eyes still on you.
"And I told you I was drunk. It's never gonna happen, Hangman." You look down at the sweatshirt you're wearing and smile, looking back to him, eager to taunt him. "I think I'll just keep collecting these while I'm here, it's more fun that way." You trace your fingers over the embroidered US Navy logo, humming.
Hangman's eyes narrow, his mouth opening to say something. The sound of voices and laughter growing closer stops him, familiar faces pouring into the room. You make a pointed smile in his direction before turning to the commotion. Natasha and Bradley are bickering about something you can't quite figure out. Some of the other guys you met last night at the Hard Deck – Bob and Payback – follow close behind them, commenting on whatever the argument was.
"All I'm saying is that when I say go, we have to go," Natasha nags.
Bradley sighs loudly, nodding. "I know, I got it, next time." You recognize that sigh, one of discontent, one he huffs to make his annoyance known. He clearly hadn't retired it. He used it with you a few times, mostly when you asked him to put aside his obsessing over work for just one night.
Hangman crosses his arms, interjecting their conversation. "Rooster's always been hesitant. It's that kind of shit that gets you killed out there."
You glance at him, not fully agreeing with his statement. Bradley had never been hesitant in all the time you'd known him. There was nothing hesitant about the way he loved you – or the way he left you behind. When he knew what he wanted, he'd drop anything for it. Including you. Pushing the thoughts aside, you look back to Rooster, his eyes locked on Hangman, a look of defiance in his glare.
"Hangman," Bradley says, looking the man up and down with obvious distaste for his lack of public decency. Seems Hangman isn't popular with most of the group and you couldn't blame them. Bradley takes a step forward from where his friends linger by the door. "You look good." His tone is dry, sarcastic, but Hangman runs with the lackluster comment. He rises from his chair, walking over to clap Rooster on the back.
"I am good, Rooster, I'm very good." His eyes move from Bradley to where you sit on the couch, his smile stretching as his eyes drink you in. Bradley follows his gaze, smiling something soft at you before turning his eyes back on Hangman, all of the kindness draining from his face, scowling.
Bob mumbles something about their training, crossing the room to the kitchen and you mentally thank him for easing the tension in the room, everyone else joining in on the new topic of conversation. Natasha pushes past Bradley and sits down next to you on the couch, knocking Bradley out of his head and back to reality. Hangman returns to perch on his barstool, leaning back cooly against the counter, drinking in the commotion his simple comment caused.
Rooster waves him off and crashes into the pillow of the couch, his knee knocking into yours as he does so. You smile and he returns it, his eyes slipping down to his sweatshirt pooling around your body.
"Oh," you exclaim, sitting up. "Here, you should take this back before I forget." You slip your arms out of the sleeves and shimmy the fabric over your neck and shoulders, a chill running down your spine as you adjust to the new temperature. Your tank top gets caught as you undress, showing the smallest strip of naked skin that you quickly work to cover, tugging the top down at your sides. You feel eyes on you and you look around the room, your eyes connecting first with Bradley's and then Hangman's, his pupils dilating at the sight of you. It takes him a second, his mind working quickly as he watches you toss the sweatshirt to Rooster, the two of you exchanging a knowing glance.
You notice Hangman's posture change out of the corner of your eye, his shoulders hunching, his hand instinctively moving to the back of his neck. He mashes his lips together in a harsh line. His eyes meet yours and you look away just as quickly, avoiding his gaze.
Rooster hums, turning your attention away from Hangman. He runs his fingers over the sweatshirt and hands the fabric back to you.
"Keep it," he smiles. "It suits you."
YOU ARE READING
HEARTFIRST (Jake "Hangman" Seresin x Reader)
Fanfiction- In which a trip down to the San Diego Naval base to visit an old friend turns out to be more than a simple reunion, as the reader finds herself in the presence of an infuriating, cocky blonde and an old flame she thought had long fizzled out. - C...
