Hmm, a game sequel that dissapointed me would have to be Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess.
I mean, it's a really good game but it fell short for my expectations. I'm more of a fan of the older Zelda games, like Windwaker, than the newer ones. Where as in Windwaker I could do whatever I wanted, AKA chase the pigs and throw them in the ocean, but Twilight Princess doesn't allow any like down time so basically it's just quest after quest.
This game even left me disinterested at times, so much so that I never got to finish the game.
