Hii everyone! These are the results for best title, judged by Kmytho
This category had 4 criteria's. How intriguing it was, worth 40 points. Creativeness/originality, worth 20 points. How much the title relates to the cover, worth 10 points and the length, worth 10 points.
Without further ado, let's get on to the scores! Here is a note from your judge.
Firstly, I would like to say that I never thought that judging a mini category like Best Title would put me in so much trouble. All of them were unique in their own way, and it was really hard for me to choose a winner! Also, even if you don't place in the top 3 it's alright, all of you did an AMAZING job!
1. ALIENS, 4 EYES by @Cratimy
How intriguing was the title, does it make you want to read more?- 35/40
How creative or original was it?- 20/20
How much does the title relate to the cover?- 9/10
Is it too long, or just the right length- 10/10
Total- 74/80
Review- Firstly, the title is perfect and goes very well with the cover but the red scribbling on the title, but I suggest it was removed because it is covering the title! The title is interesting and gives me an idea about the story, but also it made me a little bit confused!
2. Call Out| ASTRO by @silverstar_01
How intriguing is the title, does it make you want to read more?- 37/40
How creative or original is it?- 20/20
How does the title relate to the Cover- 6/10
Is it too long, or just the right length?- 10/10
Total- 73/80
Review- The title is original and of perfect length! Though I read your blurb I am not sure how it is related to the title! I might find that out after reading the book! Here is a suggestion for the cover- The Astro members need more definition( they seem really blurred out!) And the font for the title is amazing but I wish it was bolder!
3. Phantasmagoria by @seamlesslove
How intriguing is the title, does it make you want to read more?- 38/40
How creative or original is it- 16/20
Does the title, relate to the Cover- 8/10
Is it too long or just the right length?- 10/10
Total- 72/80
Review- Great job with cover, but I wish "Phantasmagoria" was straight and in bold rather than wavy! Also, I deducted your marks in the second rubrics, because this word already exists. Overall Good job!
4. Parantap Parashakti: Paving way for him by @dwarkaratna
Is the title intriguing, does it make you want to read more?- 37/40
Is the title creative or original- 20/20
Does the title, relate to the cover- 7/10
Is too long or just the right length?- 8/10
Total- 72/80
Review- The title seems to be long, because of the spelling but it is definitely original! The cover really needs work, the title is not visible and it doesn't suit the title! I recommend using a Graphic shop! Great work!
5. Past and Present by @Tanjur_Ira
Is the title intriguing,does it make you want to read more?- 38/40
Is the title creative or original- 16/20
Does the title relate to the Cover- 7/10
Is is too long or just the right length?- 10/10
Total- 71/80
Review- The title is interesting and just the right length! Here is a suggestion for you- I wish the title was placed at the bottom in bold and I wish there was one good picture of Jimin rather than two because it seems crowded! I have read the Blurb and it was good!
6. Lila Evie- House of butterflies by @WhimsySkunk
How intriguing was the title, does it make you want to read more?- 40/40
How creative or original was it?- 20/20
How much does the title relate to the Cover- 5/10
Is it too long, or just the right length?- 10/10
Total- 75/80
Review- I never thought anyone could incorporate butterflies in their title, in such a way! It really interests me how the Mc lila is related to this house of butterflies! Coming to the cover, I didn't understand what it was supposed to be until I read the blurb. I would really recommend a graphic shop on wattpad because the cover doesn't give the title and blurb justice!
7. Dead love by @Kitana085
Is the title intriguing, does it make you want to read more?- 38/40
Is the title creative or original- 19/20
Does the title relate to the Cover- 4/10
Is the title too long or just the right length?- 10/10 Total- 71/80
Review- The title is definitely intriguing and perfect! But what really bothered me throughout the judging was your cover. Of Course never judge a book by its cover, but yours has no title, it does relate to the title, it is completely plain!! I really really recommend using a Graphic shop because I feel that many readers may quit before starting to read! Except the cover, everything else was good!
8. Tales of Heart by @aurora_2604
How intriguing was the title, does it make you want to read more?- 40/40
How creative or original was it?- 20/20
How does the title relate to the cover- 10/10
Is the title too long, or is it just the right length?- 10/10 Total- 80/80
Review- The title is amazing, and I would definitely give the book a read. It is not too long and flows well! Good job with the cover, I like the way you made the Of, it gives a different effect! After reading the title and seeing the cover I was able to understand that the tales will be of Taekook!
9. What's wrong with my fan? by @ViniShah2
How intriguing was the title, does it make you want to read more?- 40/40
How creative or original was it?- 20/20
How does the title relate to the cover?- 9/10
Is the title too long, or just the right length?- 10/10 Total- 79/80
Review- According to me, the title is something new and out of the box. Even though it is slightly big, it flows well. When I saw your cover, it was simple and beautiful but I really wish you would have used the bold font style for "fan"! That's where you lost a mark! Overall good job!
10. Welcome to Mareville: Late Night Bite by @Romizabooks
How intriguing was the title, does it make you want to read more?- 40/40
How creative or original is it?- 20/20
How does it relate to the cover- 9/10
Is it too long, or just the right length?- 10/10
Total- 79/80
Review- The title is long, but creative! What really caught my attention was that the title gives me the adult fiction category vibes but when I saw the tag humor, It really made me want to read the story! I think the cover could've been a little bit better, maybe a better picture in the background!
WINNERS:
🥇1st place: Tales of Heart by aurora_2604
🥈2nd place: Welcome to Mareville: Late Night Bite by Romizabooks and What's wrong with my fan? by ViniShah2
🥉3rd place: Lila Evie: House of Butterflies by WhimsySkunk
As you can see there was a tie for 2nd place. Congratulations to all the winners! Pls pm me for your prizes, thank you!
YOU ARE READING
The Midnight Mini Category Awards 2023
Random(✔️) Open (✔️) Judging ( ) Closed This is a new award hosted by me! hope you enjoy!
