Killer's Case Files

Evelyn Dick

Evelyn Dick was born 13th October 1920 in Beamsville, Ontario. Her parents were Scottish immigrants Donald and Alexandra MacLean. A year after her birth, her family moved to 214 Rosslyn Avenue, Hamilton, Ontario. Her father worked for the Hamilton Street Railway as a streetcar conductor. 

She was suspected of and arrested for murder after 5 local children in Hamilton, Ontario found the torso of her missing estranged Russian husband, known as John Dick. His head and limbs had been sawn from his body and were disposed of in the furnace of her home at 32 Carrick Avenue. 

She was defended in her first murder trial in 1946 by J.J. Sullivan, convicted and sentenced to hang, but her lawyer J.J. Robinette appealed her case and won an eventual acquittal. In the meantime, however, a partly mummified body of a male infant was found in her attic, encased in cement in an old suitcase. The infant was identified as her son Peter David White. 

She was tried for the baby's murder in 1947 and sentenced to life in prison, but was paroled in 1958 after serving only 11 years in Kingston's Prison for Women, with a new identity and job and disappeared from public view and her file was permanently sealed after her 1985 pardon.

A well known school yard song, (with a double entendre) at the time of the murders went as follows:

You cut off his legs...

You cut off his arms...

You cut off his head...

How could you Mrs Dick?

How could you Mrs Dick?

The Forgotten Rebels used these lyrics for the song "Evelyn Dick" on their album in 1989.

In 2001 Canadian author Brian Vallée authored The Torso Murder: The Untold Story of Evelyn Dick a book focusing on Evelyn's murder trial and subsequent disappearance. A 2002 television movie, Torso: The Evelyn Dick Story, suggests Evelyn protected her parents, who were also viable suspects in the murder of her baby and husband, and that she was sexually abused by her father and exploited by both parents to provide them a higher standing and income. The movie originally scheduled to be aired on 11th September 2001, but was delayed until 18th March 2002 due to the terrorist attacks on the original air date. The case was also the subject of the 2005 film noir musical, Black Widow.