Rule number 4: If a girl falls into the following criteria, she is off limits forever until the end of time: A) Was a bro's ex-girlfriend. B) Your bro specifically told you he wanted her. C) Is your bro's sister.

Nick Maguire is the King player of East High. He knows better than anyone that when it comes to Eliza O'Connor, his best friend's sister, He can have two of the following: True love, honesty, or his best friend's respect.
I can't stand girls like this 
You want to experience it yourself though? I'm fine with that.☺️
And this is where I'll be living 4 years from now 'pizza city'
I slightly altered the cast list-

Nick- Neil Patrick Harris

That's when I grab the plate like an idiot and scream, "OH SHIZ THATS HOT WHY DIDNT YOU FREAKING WARN ME!!"
Incest man, that's incest... xD jk but talk about messed up plot twist!
I just have to say....