Liana Liberato as Olivia Abbott
—"Lover boy in the flesh. Maybe I'll go tell him about your stalking problem."
Aaron Taylor Johnson as James Potter
—"Everyone's in love with me."
Peyton List as Georgia Lockheart
—"How do you not know who James Potter is?"
Alex Pettyfer as Gilderoy Lockheart
—"Don't make me tell you to shut up."
Ben Barnes as Sirius Black
—"Why the sudden interest in the girl anyway?"
Andrew Garfield as Remus Lupin
—"You can't tell anyone."
Dane Dehaan as Peter Pettigrew
—"I don't sing! My father does, but not me!"
Sophie Skelton as Lily Evans
—"I was worried the Wicked Witch had done something."
Ian Bohen as Charlus Potter
—"Oh, you poor, naive little girl. This has always been so much bigger than some stupid hair gel."