Kaylee's older twin sister Katlyn runs into phone trouble so she calls a customer service line to help her and meets Alex. While he's helping her with her phone he can't help but notice her voice. He thinks of bringing it up but brushes it off. After the appointment, she gets up to leave but before she gets a chance to, Alex writes her a receipt with his number on it. She calls the number and the two set up a date at Kaylee's twin sister Katlyn's coffee shop. The next day Alex gets to the shop and realizes why Katlyn looked so familiar. Back in high school Alex had a crush on Katlyn and tells Kaylee about it and decides to try and keep the two as far away from one another as possible. Alex takes Kaylee back to his place and they officially start dating. Kaylee chose to stay away from her phone to avoid any of her family's negativity. Katlyn stirs with concern since Kaylee isn't known to not answer calls and not return text messages. Amidst all of this Katyln realize She drives to her location and asked to speak to Kaylee in private, Alex refuses to move so she confronts her in front of him and then comes into the house and heads upstairs to talk to Alex who has locked himself into his spare bedroom. Katlyn finds a key and uses it to get into the room, as both of them confess their love for one another something happens, causing a love triangle to form. Who will Alex choose,Katlyn or Kaylee?