Erin Garnett has a huge crush on Will Thorne but does not have the guts to confess to him, knowing that He already rejected several women for unknown reasons. At a college party, Erin was able to confess to him, and just like the other women, she got rejected. Having her heart broken by the one she really loved, she got unexpectedly involved with Derek Thorne, Will's half-brother and the one she hated the most. What will become of Erin having the two brothers in her life? Will she be loved? Or will she be hurt?