He fooled her once but never again He played her once but never again Once upon a time, Abigail Manhattan's innocence got her landed right at a big bad monster's hand. He played her right at the palm of his hands, made a fool of her. But never again is she making the same mistake twice. She was a fool once but never again. She knows better than to trust a man, especially those who like to invade one's life as a knight in shining armor only to trash one's heart like a useless toy after their fill.