Best friends, Abbey, Camilla, Elle and Tai all have one thing in common: they are all painfully inexperienced when it comes to guys. But as luck would have it, each of them start their sophomore year by stumbling into unexpected relationships with the likes of the most popular guy in school, a dork-turned-stud, a witty rebel, and a shy yet hopeless romantic. As the girls experience a number of "firsts", they also learn a few things about themselves and their new beaus along the way.