- We Are 2 Different To Be In-love (Eyeless Jack x Jeff the Killer) Complete
- Reads 17,234
- Votes 420
- Parts 10
- Time 37m
"I am making out with my Cookies" Jeff says as he eats a chocolate cookie. "what?" Ej questions him. - Murder - EJ x Reader - COMPLETED Complete
- Reads 194,930
- Votes 5,778
- Parts 15
- Time 1h 3m
An Eyeless Jack x Reader. Read it and find out what it's about. Hey that rhymed. Kinda shitty, you've been warned. •COMPLETED: JUNE 21ST, 2019• - The Horror and Pleasure of Our Love (Jeff The Killer x Eyeless Jack fanfic) Complete
- Reads 113,117
- Votes 2,247
- Parts 15
- Time 1h 1m
Is being in love with a cannibal bad enough? <<containts smut in some Chapters>> YAOI FANFIC - (DISCONTINUED) Creepypasta 7 minutes in heaven Complete
- Reads 17,069
- Votes 189
- Parts 7
- Time 19m
The story will include (hopefully I can't guaretee cause I might get lazy and give up on this story) EJ, Ticci Toby, Jeff, Ben and maybe more - Jeff the killer x Eyeless Jack [COMPLETED] Complete
- Reads 17,131
- Votes 260
- Parts 8
- Time 13m
Jeff x EJ - Jeff x eyeless jack Complete
- Reads 79,924
- Votes 1,499
- Parts 19
- Time 36m
The title says it soooo this will be the more cringe creepypasta ship story eva - Eyeless Jack x Reader Complete
- Reads 273,804
- Votes 7,181
- Parts 14
- Time 1h 3m
Eyeless Jack, has recently taken a liking to someone. That just happens to be you. This is my first fanfic, the first chapter would be the worst (Coming from me, as in the writer), but hey give it a shot. - Creepypasta: All Characters x Reader (One Shots); Seven Minutes in Hell Complete
- Reads 267,592
- Votes 2,846
- Parts 9
- Time 31m
Just a common Creepypasta Seven Minutes in Heaven. Reader insert and also beware of warnings. The story contains: gore, rape themes, curses, smut (lemons) and much more. Please be aware of those before starting to read this~ - Rose Petals - Eyeless Jack x Reader Complete
- Reads 45,327
- Votes 1,639
- Parts 28
- Time 5h 51m
You always wanted a way out of town and away from the trauma of your every day life, but who knew it would come to you in a blue mask? Your life was certainly troubled. You had no parents- they were stripped away from you by a faceless thing in the woods one night when you were a small child. You had a troubled friend group. You had a stressful, mind-numbing minimum wage job. You had a broken home, completed by the drunken, careless uncle who had once promised to take care of you and your siblings. It made you want to disappear. The grey man dressed in black was a surprise to you after a chaotic night at home, and it was just his luck you even found him. However, what you thought to be a strange new friend was lethal and full of old horrors, and you soon come to find that he wants to be much more than just friends. (Cover art belongs to me!) Started: 8/26/2022 First Published: 10/15/2022 Finished: [Pending] - ℐ𝓈𝓈𝓊ℯ𝓈 ✔︎ Complete
- Reads 3,776
- Votes 75
- Parts 6
- Time 8m
Jack has trust issues and lets no one near him, not even the other proxies that live with him bother to talk to him unless it's considered mandatory. Toby Adams - or more known as Ticci Toby - tries to befriend Jack as to show the cannibal that not everyone is all bad and distrustful. And maybe fall in love while doing so? - CreepyPasta x Reader Complete
- Reads 161,560
- Votes 2,412
- Parts 7
- Time 46m
CURRENTLY BEING REWORKED - Our Daughter (Slenderman x Female Reader) Ongoing
- Reads 70,607
- Votes 2,695
- Parts 33
- Time 4h 34m
Sally sings a song you used to always sing to her when she was alive. She never forgot it even after she was murdered. You never forget the song and you're determined to prove your little girl isn't actually dead.
You are seeing 15 of 7.2K results