Bryn is a 27-year-old school teacher who has just ended an 8-year relationship with Tyler, a beautiful and troubled man with whom she has shared many firsts. During her grief, she reconnects with God, begins new relationships, and eventually meets Shin. Shin is a Godly, handsome, and stable presence in Bryn's life, but things get complicated when Tyler begins singing his own song of redemption and once again pursues Bryn. Will Bryn choose Tyler and get the "Happily ever after" she's attempted many times before, or will she stay out of her comfort zone and give new love a chance?