Natalie Athlon is the exact image of her dead mother's cousin. And she even happens to have her same name. Anthony Garrett happened to be in love with the original Natalie, and when she died - he was stuck with the curse of immortality, never moving forward. It's been years since then and when he decides to go to college for the first time, he meets Natalie's next generation. But when the new Natalie brings him home, his nephew whom he once thought was his son, recognizes him from his memories. Now all Anthony has to worry about is if the family will welcome him back, especially with his wierd attraction to their blood.