As a last-ditch effort to heal her heartbreak, Lyla starts writing letters to the most popular boy in school, who also happens to be the contender for valedictorian and captain of the football team... but before all that, he'd just been James. Her James. It isn't until Lyla's amassed a notebook full of letters to him that she starts to realise that maybe the whole reason she can't stop writing to him is because their story isn't finished after all. But, like life, it might not have the happy ending she's been holding out for. Or maybe it does... and it's just with the last person she ever expected.