You know things can't be good when you have two high schools in the same town that hate each other. Baseball and softball are the two most popular sports at these two schools. So when Lincoln High and Jones High come together to play the towns favorite two games of the entire season, things are going to get serious. It's senior year for both Caleb, pitcher for Jones High, and Alex, pitcher for Lincoln. They are both determined to win this game. And they'll do whatever it takes to make that happen. Well, Caleb's team for sure. Brennan creates a plan that he is certain will help lead Jones High baseball team to victory. This requires Caleb to go and pretend he is crazy in love with Alex. She's the perfect target for this plan. She's crazy about softball and could probably tell you anything you wanted to know about their baseball team. Brennan thinks that Alex will spit all this information out about their baseball team to Caleb. Caleb will come back to report it and that's how they'll know what to do in their huge game against them. But instead of Caleb pretending to like her, he accidentally really falls for her. He finds himself totally forgetting about the plan and the game coming up. Alex is his main focus and is all Caleb can concentrate on. Caleb now has a choice. He can keep the girl he is so madly in love with and let down his team or Alex is just way out of Caleb's league. He can dump her and help his team win the most important game of the year. Whatever decision he makes, will all lead to a huge disaster.