For some people, love someone is not a big thing but what if you love two person at the same time and you have to choose one? And this is happen to Madison. Madison Collins is the head of cheerio in William McKinley High School. She is dating the quarterback, Finn Hudson. Everything was fine until one day, Finn and her join the glee club and there is some kind of "weird" feeling between Madison and Noah Puckerman. How come? What happen? Who will she choose? Finn Hudson or Noah Puckerman?