You're Different - H2OVanoss
Jonathan's a nobody in High School. His only friend is Luke and soon enough, he ditches him too. The school bully, Evan, bets his friend, Tyler, that he's so hot he could even get a guy to fall for him and his target is Jonathan. Jonathan begins to fall for Evan. Hard. But when he finds out the truth upon why Evan is being so nice to him, he pushes him away and tries to stop his feelings. Little does Jonathan know, Evan might just like him back, but what will Jonathan do to get him back when he leaves and returns a year later, different?
(This story doesn't get good until Chapter Twenty or so.)