Joshua Grayson is not happy about his new sister-in-law's visit and he uses the term 'sister-in-law' loosely as Careen Kennedy Grayson was a complete stranger. Joshua's brother, Matthew, left the family ranch in the dead of night to run away and wed a woman he'd never met. The fact Matthew was killed moments after walking out of the church with his new bride merely adds insult to injury. Joshua struggles with resentment and trying not to blame Careen for his brother's death. But it is difficult not to harbor ill feelings when he knows she's keeping secrets. Despite his suspicions, Joshua slowly grows attracted to Careen and even starts to like her. Unfortunately, Joshua knows all too well the folly of loving a woman he cannot trust.
Careen Kennedy Grayson was married and widowed within minutes of the other. When her obsessive cousin, Luther, arrives minutes after Matthew's death, she knows deep down he's the one who killed Matthew. Luther is arrested and held for trial while Careen takes her husband's body back to his family. Soon after arriving at the loving Grayson ranch, Careen learns of her mother-in-law's heart condition. Unwilling to cause undue stress, Careen decides to wait until after Luther's trial to speak the full truth of their son's death. Soon Careen grows embedded in family and ranch life, getting closer to the Grayson's with each passing day. She finds herself unnaturally drawn to Joshua and she knows their budding attraction will only complicate matters... Especially when the family discovers her cousin did indeed kill Matthew.