I can't feel pain but I can feel love.(Ticci...
Y/N has always known Toby. Only because when they were in school, Toby wasn't always the only one bullied.
But when they meet again as 'crazed killers' they remain friends, but what about Toby's other friends.
And, he instantly recognized her, even though she doesn't. Not at first at least.
She also hides as a boy once she becomes a Creepypasta, for further reasons unknown until you read the story.
But also, she falls for the boy who can't feel pain. But can he feel love?
(The 'hiding as a boy' part is originally from @KILLEREBEL5 so yeah...)