Sleeping with someone for the first time was supposed to be special; at least, that was what Kelsey Morrison had always thought. With very few memories of the night of the event, and even fewer memories of the guy who deflowered her, she spends the first term of her senior year of high school trying to find him. Unfortunately, her one and only clue leads to three boys; the school player, her workmate, and her brothers’ best friend. But can she uncover the identity of the mysterious boy before her blackmailer leaks her secret through the school? Or is her blackmailer the mysterious boy?