Chris Hart is just your-so-not average kind of guy. He's nowhere near average, he's way below average. He's never been in a relationship, never attempted to and never felt the need to. Nothing wrong with that, right? That is until he strikes a deal with Jake White, one of the popular guys at school. The deal doesn't entail much, all he has to do is tutor Jake math and Jake helps him with physical education. The only problem is, strange things start to happen during these tutorial sessions. The complication: Jake is Chris' sister's boyfriend and Lilly isn't someone to be messed with, sibling or not. Apart having to deal with his sexuality, Chris finds out a secret about himself that threatens to topple his little world.