Creepypasta Boyfriend scenarios

Creepypasta Boyfriend scenarios

110K Reads 2.3K Votes 55 Part Story
Puppyswim By Puppyswim Updated Oct 01

Ever wondered what it would be like to date a killer? No, of course not but here you are! 

Meet the creepypasta of your dreams 😉

  • ben
  • boyfriend
  • creepypasta
  • eyelessjack
  • fanfiction
  • hoodieandmasky
  • jeff
  • liu
  • lostsilver
  • love
  • puppyswim
  • ticcitoby
Suspirius-hearts Suspirius-hearts Aug 14, 2016
Hiya! Would you be interested in reading my Ticci Toby x reader story? It's okay if you don't lol I'm just looking for fellow Toby lovers who'd enjoy it😂
- - Nov 24, 2016
I wrote lots of stories and leave them in my folders 
                              So later when I come back and read them I can be like
                              OH GOD WHAT DID I WRITE
                              ....
                              They are weird stories.
MrMilktrayMan MrMilktrayMan Dec 13, 2016
Am I the only one that that's screaming NUUUUUUUU because there ain't no ICONIC SLENDYMAN?!
LouiseBlyth LouiseBlyth Aug 04, 2016
Add suicide mouse,SONIC EXE,Dr Smiley,The Rake(in human form),Smile Dog(human) and offender