When the two new kids roll into town Sophie is amazed at how beautiful the twins are, and how different they are. Ethan acts like the perfect guy, carefree, has that spark that makes all the girls at school swoon at his perfect body and dark brown hair. Damon is entirely different. He is cautious, thoughtful, and amazing. But both of our perfect guys are keeping a dark secret. They made a bet that the first one to "pop Sophie's cherry" to win bragging rights and mommy and daddy's insanely expensive house in the Hamptons, in the will. Well unbeknownst to them, Sophie isn't a virgin.