As sisters Alex and Elena Gilbert try to move past the death of their parents, both vow to make things different, for their brother Jeremy and their aunt Jenna, but most of all themselves. They both find its harder than they thought, especially when vampire brothers Stefan and Damon blows into town, and they're both sucked into the dangerous world of the supernatural. Even with the danger they are always in together, Alex vows to help and protect Elena, now matter what happens, even if it's standing up to Damon, the brother she hates, while also struggling to keep secrets from her family and friends, and an expected person that has found a liking to her. Elena doesn't have that problem with Stefan, and while Elena starts to trust Damon, Alex believes that she would always hate him, even with the feelings he has for both sisters, even if it isn't love for both of them, or is it? . . . One question lingers in her mind: Is it possible to love two people at once?