(Y/N) is a normal boy, with a normal school, normal personality, almost normal everything. He however has a not so normal dad. His father is Vincent and he recently murdered 5 children at a local pizzeria and was arrested soon after. Now living with a foster mom, (Y/N) now has to deal with the weird looks and harsh comments from everyone at school. With all this going on, 5 new students are now attending Crystal High, the same high school as (Y/N). 4 of them are girls and all five have gained popularity from just their looks alone. What happens when the four gals are crushing on the same boy?