Between Us Three // Lottie Matthews & Natalie Scatorccio
- Reads 29,516
- Votes 1,388
- Parts 19
MatureOngoing18h 7m
Last published Fri, Nov 7, 2025
You've moved around your whole life. New towns, new schools, new people. You stopped getting attached a long time ago. Wiskayok was just supposed to be just another stop: keep your head down, focus on graduating and disappear like you always do.
But that plan starts to fall apart the moment you catch the attention of two very different girls: one quiet and magnetic and the other with sharp edges and soft warnings like a dare you're not sure you should take.
You quickly realize, staying invisible was never going to last.
-----
PAIRINGS:
• Lottie Matthews x You x Natalie Scatorccio
• Minor mentions of Taivan
• Minor mentions of... other pairings (wink wink)
WARNINGS:
• G!P Reader
• Explicit Language
• Sexual Content (smut)
-----
Story can be found on AO3. I usually update on there first. :)
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
The Sidelines of Love (Intersex - GxG)
Looking from the sidelines watching cheerleaders getting tossed in the air, footballs being thrown, people getting tackled, people shouting and yelling, and coaches tossing their clipboards in the grass. But, I only see you. With your long curly hair, your siren amber eyes, your alluring smile, your laugh. You're popular, the head cheerleader, and you're dating the captain of the football team, and I'm just someone in the background on the sidelines.... a mascot. °☆☆° P.S- I love to read y'alls comments! :3☺️ #2 on Cheerleader - July 6th, 2025 #4 on gxg- September 7th, 2025 #6 on intersex- September 3rd, 2025 #1 on angstwithhappyending- July 7th, 2025 #7 on popular- July 24th, 2025 #1on teens- January 21th, 2026 #1 on awkward- August 9th, 2025 #2 on wlw- August 7th, 2025 #2 on slowburn- August 23th, 2025Complete
THE HIVE - Lottie Matthews
Madison Shipman always thrived under pressure. The younger sister of Shauna Shipman, she was a star player on the Yellowjackets, a straight-A student, and determined to make it into Harvard. Balancing soccer, academics, and the expectations placed on her, Maddie was used to pushing herself past her limits, until the plane crash that changed everything. Stranded in the wilderness with her teammates, Maddie is forced to confront a brutal new reality where survival demands sacrifices she never imagined. Her friendships with the girls take on new meaning in the face of hunger and fear, and her growing connection with Lottie becomes something deeper, something Maddie can't explain, even as it consumes her. Fem OC x Lottie Matthews Season 1 : finished Season 2: finished Season 3: on going![Feels Like Home • Maya Hart [1] | ✓](https://img.wattpad.com/cover/307863892-256-k727640.jpg)
Feels Like Home • Maya Hart [1] | ✓
"my life had changed in ways I couldn't rearrange and all I saw was you." • • • Maya catches feelings for a new student. She's never felt this way in a long time, except when she saw Josh Matthews. She's confused, and afraid. But Maya Hart never feels that way. Right? Oh, but why now? Because her crush is a girl. • • • Maya Hart x OC centric. This story is a work of fiction. This story contains mature content including, but not limited to: gxg, coarse language, sickness, anxiety and depression. Do not interact if you are a minor & if these themes are not suitable for you. • [First draft]Complete
In Love With My Band Mate - a Camren love story
When Lauren Jauregui auditioned for The X Factor, she saw this really pretty girl. Lauren could only see her from a distance, but she could already tell she was beautiful. She had wished she wasn't so shy at moments like this. Because, If she wasn't, she could maybe talk to her. "I caught myself staring at her. I don't know if it was the neon pants or her beauty, but something just pulled my eyes towards her and I couldn't take them off of her. " At the next auditioning round, Lauren finds out that the cute girl's name is Camila Cabello. They start talking, and Lauren is immediately star struck. Camila's eyes were so beautiful. Of course, brown is a common eye color, but still, hers had something special. Her eyes weren't the only things she liked about Camila. There was so much more. Her pretty brown hair, her full lips, her beautiful voice and her cute smile. When Camila surprised Lauren by asking her her number, Lauren's smile just couldn't leave her face for the whole day. She couldn't wait to get to know Camila better, but what if she didn't get the chance to? That thought soon left her mind when a certain girl band is formed, called Fifth Harmony. But what happens when Lauren's feelings for Camila grow stronger and stronger? Started: January 2017Complete
Blame it on the Snowfall | YELLOWJACKETS
natalie scatorccio (thinks she) loathes two things above all else: christmas and lottie matthews. But when an unexpected twist of fate forces her to confront both, she begins to uncover a holiday magic she never believed in-hidden within the person she despises most. NO CRASH AU lottie x nat enemies to lovers / slow burnComplete
American teenager
"Say what you want, but say it like you mean it, with your fists for once" When the plane went down, they were just girls. By the time they were found, they were something else entirely. Ziggy never meant to fall in love in the wilderness, least of all with Natalie - reckless, magnetic, and just as broken as she was. But survival carves strange paths through the heart. Decades later, Ziggy is a single mother, haunted by what happened out there and what it cost them all. When a postcard brings back old memories and old friends, the past begins to unravel - one secret at a time. Yellowjackets fanfic Natalie ScatorccioXfemale Oc S1-??
Her or the Hunger
lottie matthews x female reader x natalie scatorccio Y/N always kept to the sidelines. As the co-equipment manager for the Yellowjackets, she was the quiet one, the helper, the one who made sure everyone had what they needed-on and off the field. Including her feelings for two girls she never thought would notice her: Lottie Matthews, the dreamy, rich girl with a god-complex in the making, and Natalie Scatorccio, all edge, eyeliner, and bruised knuckles. She had been crushing on both of them since forever. Then the crash happened. Now they're stuck in the wilderness for nineteen months. Starving, unraveling, doing whatever it takes to survive. Lottie becomes a leader of something that's starting to feel like a cult. Natalie's falling apart. And Y/N? She's stuck in the middle. Of their madness. Of their rivalry. Of her feelings. And the worst part? She might still be in love with both of them. Love was complicated enough before they started eating people. Warning(s): you know how Yellowjacket goes, don't be surprised if shit gets crazy 7.14.25 - ranked #1 in "lottiematthews" 8.05.25 ranked #12 in "nataliescatorccio" 9.18.25 - ranked #2 in "yellowjacketsfanfic"
She's the danger I crave to taste ( gxg intersex )
"Willow, wait." Blake's voice was rough, her breath coming in uneven gasps as my fingers unzipped her fly. "Before we go any further, this is your last chance to stop me." I frowned. "Why would I?" "Because if you let me take you now, you're mine. Forever." Her intense gaze burned into me. "And there will be no turning back." ==== Willow's life is a desperate rhythm of morning lectures, late-night shifts, a messy family, and counting every dollar just to make it through. Blake is her classmate, the girl everyone on campus fears. Some say she has ties to the Mafia, others claim she deals in things far worse. But one thing is certain. No one dares to mess with her because those who have ended up in the hospital. One night, on her way home after another exhausting shift, Willow finds Blake bleeding out on the street. Against every instinct, she helps her. But Blake, as it turns out, isn't the kind of person who lets debts go unpaid. When Willow's stepfather aggressively demands money from her, Blake steps in and handles it without hesitation. Now, questions haunt Willow. Who is Blake really? Are the rumors about her true? And most terrifying of all, why can't she stop thinking about her knowing that whatever burns between them is destined for destruction? Be careful this story contains: Profanity Smut ViolenceComplete
Looking from the sidelines watching cheerleaders getting tossed in the air, footballs being thrown, people getting tackled, people shouting and yelling, and coaches tossing their clipboards in the grass. But, I only see you. With your long curly hair, your siren amber eyes, your alluring smile, your laugh. You're popular, the head cheerleader, and you're dating the captain of the football team, and I'm just someone in the background on the sidelines.... a mascot. °☆☆° P.S- I love to read y'alls comments! :3☺️ #2 on Cheerleader - July 6th, 2025 #4 on gxg- September 7th, 2025 #6 on intersex- September 3rd, 2025 #1 on angstwithhappyending- July 7th, 2025 #7 on popular- July 24th, 2025 #1on teens- January 21th, 2026 #1 on awkward- August 9th, 2025 #2 on wlw- August 7th, 2025 #2 on slowburn- August 23th, 2025
More detailsContent Guidelines