The choice is hers
- Reads 21,179
- Votes 841
- Parts 18
MatureOngoing4h 21m
Last published Sun, May 31, 2026
‼️READ THE DESCRIPTION. ‼️
Kylie Cantrall recently dumped her boyfriend, Malachi Barton, after walking in on him and her so called bff, Sofia Wylie.
At the first game of the season she's looking for revenge. Kylie marches over to the rival team's captain, Malia Baker, and kisses her. As Kylie pulls away to savor the shock on her ex's face, Malia pulls her back. Kylie hears rowdy cheers from one side of the field, and boos from the other.
But an unexpected twist makes Kylie have to choose between a fake relationship or a real one.
All Rights Reserved
Join the largest storytelling communityGet personalized story recommendations, save your favourites to your library, and comment and vote to grow your community.
You may also like
Enemies to Lovers - Kylia story
Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker were once inseparable - childhood best friends with matching bracelets and late-night video calls that never ended in goodbyes. But everything changed the day Malia disappeared without a word. No texts. No explanations. Just silence. Two years later, Malia's back - colder, sharper, and with a mysterious edge that Kylie doesn't recognize... or trust. The betrayal still burns in Kylie's chest, and it doesn't help that Malia acts like she never cared in the first place. Tension sparks the moment they reunite. The hallway stares. The biting remarks. The undeniable chemistry. What neither of them wants to admit is that under the bitterness lies something unspoken. Something real. But with old wounds, buried secrets, and their tight-knit friend group caught in the crossfire, Kylie and Malia must decide: will they let the past define them, or risk everything for what might still be burning between them? Enemies by fate. Lovers by choice... if they can survive each other first.Complete
Back to You: Book 1
malias mom is a traveling nurse. back in the summer before her junior year of high school malia had to move to canada becauee of her moms job. this caused kylie and malia to break up after malia moved. this year (senior year) malia is unexpectedly moving back to LA and returning to school with her friends and kylie. they havent seen or talked to each other in a year... until NOW! or not we'll seeComplete
you, me & nyc
malia baker has been counting down the days until senior year was over. she thought graduation meant she'd never have to deal with kylie cantrall again - loud, cocky, impossible kylie, who somehow always knew how to get under her skin. but the universe (or at least their school's senior trip) had other plans. now malia's stuck sharing a bus, a room, and way too much time with the girl she's spent years trying to forget. but something about this trip feels... different. kylie still drives her crazy, sure - but in a way that's harder to walk away from this time. and the longer they're stuck together in the city that never sleeps, the harder it is to remember why she hated her in the first place.Complete
THE ONE NIGHT STAND
Malia Baker, a 19 year old who just went through a break up, she tried to push everything away, but couldn't. so being the dumb teenager she is, well shes very smart but not the point, she puts all her feelings into one cage, the last shattered piece of her heart. locked it and threw it away by drinking, smoking and way more. She decided to go to a bar far from her usual area. she drank until all she could say was "more" as in more damn shots. anyways. until she meets this black haired stunning woman....
Controlled Reactions.
In high school, chemistry isn't just for the lab. Malia Baker has her entire future mapped out-top grades, championship water polo seasons, and zero distractions. Kylie Cantrall has charm, status, and a sharp tongue that cuts deeper than most rumors about her. When a surprise science competition threatens Kylie's GPA and graduation, she's paired-against all odds-with Malia, the one girl who sees through her games. Malia wants to win. Kylie wants to coast. But neither expected their clashing worlds to spark something more dangerous than rivalry. As late-night study sessions turn to quiet confrontations and secrets slip through guarded glances, the line between hate and something else begins to blur. But with Kylie's friends warning her to stay away, and Malia's family watching her every move, both girls are forced to ask: how far will you go for someone you're not supposed to fall for? - This is a fan-fiction based on Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker. this is not their real lives whatsoever. Kylie and Malia are full grown adults. This is just a story! The content of this fic will may cause disturbance to some viewers as it may hit sensitive topics and sexual scenes. I will always have a trigger warning before each of these chapters so everyone can be aware of they are going to read. This is an original story and i will NOT be focused on adding people the two girls know irl. A lot of the characters are fictional such as Kylie and Malia. I hope everyone enjoys this story and if you have any ideas about it feel free to dm me on TikTok or instagram!! TikTok: vspjxsq Instagram: vspjxssq Happy reading everyone! 💗
Anyone but you.
Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker used to date back in high school. However, Something ugly happened between the lovebirds, causing both of them to never wish to speak to each other again. Therefore, when they both end up at the same university....in the same dorm...things get a bit out of hand. (Did someone say lovers to enemies to lovers?) -warning signs shown when smut included-
Eventually (kylia)
Kylie's always been the kind of girl who falls too fast and feels too deeply, though ever since a brutal breakup left her traumatized, she's never been the same. Before the breakup, she was all in, a hopeless romantic, loyal to a fault, and crazy in love. She gave everything to someone who promised forever, only to be betrayed. It felt like being kissed on the forehead while a knife was sliding between her ribs. Tender, calculated, and devastatingly personal. The pain wasn't just emotional; it was identity-shattering. This new Kylie's known for two things: wild nights and a heart locked behind sarcasm and tequila. Feelings? Overrated. But everything changes the night her best friend throws a college party and she meets Malia. Malia's a quiet, soft-spoken, clever girl with curly brown hair and eyes that seem to ask all the right questions. That night, they hit it off right away. Maybe it was their chemistry, or maybe it was just the tequila. Though the day after the party goes a bit differently. Kylie does what she always does: flirts, charms, and makes her move. But Malia isn't like the others. She turns Kylie down, gently but firmly, explaining she's not interested in meaningless flings. She wants something real. And the for first time in years, Kylie finds herself wanting to slow down, to dig deeper, and maybe, revert to the old, lover-girl version of herself, or possibly, be the kind of person someone like Malia could fall for. Little does she know, love really does make you crazy. TW: mature language, alcohol, substance abuse, murder, and some other sensitive subjects.Complete
OFFSIDE
Kylie and Malia have always been inseparable - co-captains of their high school soccer team, star players, and best friends since forever. Their connection on the field is effortless. Off the field? A little more complicated. When Malia starts dating a guy - charming, athletic, and jealous - Kylie tries to be supportive. But something inside her shifts. The more time Malia spends with him, the more distant she feels. And the more Kylie starts to realize her feelings for Malia might go deeper than friendship. Now, stuck between a secret love, a complicated friendship, and a tense season on the field, Kylie has to decide: does she keep her heart hidden - or risk everything?Complete
Kylie Cantrall and Malia Baker were once inseparable - childhood best friends with matching bracelets and late-night video calls that never ended in goodbyes. But everything changed the day Malia disappeared without a word. No texts. No explanations. Just silence. Two years later, Malia's back - colder, sharper, and with a mysterious edge that Kylie doesn't recognize... or trust. The betrayal still burns in Kylie's chest, and it doesn't help that Malia acts like she never cared in the first place. Tension sparks the moment they reunite. The hallway stares. The biting remarks. The undeniable chemistry. What neither of them wants to admit is that under the bitterness lies something unspoken. Something real. But with old wounds, buried secrets, and their tight-knit friend group caught in the crossfire, Kylie and Malia must decide: will they let the past define them, or risk everything for what might still be burning between them? Enemies by fate. Lovers by choice... if they can survive each other first.
More detailsContent Guidelines