a/n: This is a sequel to Sweet Treats. You don't HAVE to read it but I suggest you do. IM SO EXCITED! I HAVE GREAT THINGS PLANNED!!!!!! the puns...
~one month later~
Jeff looked down at Toby as he ate his waffles.
"Why do you love those so much?" Toby looked up at Jeff and pointed to his boyfriend, Masky, who was sitting close by.
"It's because when I lick the butter and syrup off my lips, it makes him horny. I love messing with him." Jeff eyes wide (when aren't they) walked back to his spot on the carpet picking up the game controller. Slendy had made a new rule that all the pastas in the mansion had to spend their Tuesday nights in the living room for "bonding time".
"We're still going to that horror movie this weekend, right?" Toby asked Masky. Masky was about to say something but Hoodie interrupted.
"Is it that movie with the bird?" Hoodie blurted out swirling his head away from the computer to look at the other two men.
"Yeah." Masky chuc...