Wyatt and Seth Lowell want a new start. They are moving across the country and are hoping that they can leave the past behind them. With the help of a judge the two were able to change their identities. The two brothers are now Wyatt and Seth Taylor who live in Denver, Colorado.
They don't expect much when they get to Colorado. Truthfully, they're just hoping to graduate high school then worry about life and college. However, they meet some friends - Jason Walker and Gavin Slater - that manage to change their perspectives on life. Only Seth get's the biggest realization out of anyone. He has always been a little confused toward his sexuality so taking his fresh start in full swing he decides to figure out whether he likes guys or, maybe, one guy in particular.
It seems as life is finally beginning to work itself out, a fresh start is a little too much to ask for. Seth and Wyatt are forced back into the problems of their former life and it's up to Jason and Gavin to help them out of it. As secrets and hated memories are released its up to the brothers to figure out if second chances are truly worth it.