Overshadowed by her sisters perfect example all her life, Spencer has given up trying to be the person people want her to be. Her wannabe good girl reputation is gone, in its place: a she-devil. But then Spence finds someone, someone that she would have rather kept buried in her past. The boy she once loved, adored, and hated all at the same time was back, and he wasn't going to let go until he got Spencer to be his again. One problem: her twin sister hates the boy and would do anything to keep him out of Spence's life. Torn between her sister, who has been by her side her whole life, and the man who will stop at nothing to make her his, Spencer is forced to make a choice. A choice that could end her relationship with her lifelong companion, or terminate her option to have a future with the boy she loves.