Theo Anderson, the popular quarterback, wanted nothing but to get the golden girl Effie Sanders. But turns out he was wrong, as the popular Effie was nothing but wild and stuck-up, not to mention getting drunk in way too many parties. All he wanted was a girl he could love, no matter how unfamiliar it all is to him. Then here comes the enigmatic, carefree Gwen Summers who comes in new at the middle of the semester, extremely sarcastic with a filter-free mouth and who effortlessly mystifies boys in school. And Theo, is no exception to that. But this Gwen Summers is keeping some secrets Theo would do anything to find out.