When Gabriella was in fifth grade she moved from Indianapolis to Ohio, leaving her two best friends behind, Amanda and Matthew. She tried to stay in communication with both of her friends, but life got busy for all of them and the effort to talk to each other creased. Five years later, Gabriella moved back to Indianapolis due to her dad's job. When Gabby returns, she befriends a preschool classmate who belongs to her pool and a first grade classmate who has youth group with her, but will Amanda, Matthew, and Gabriella resume their friendship? What happens when Gabriella realizes she has a crush on one of her best friends? Only time will tell Gabriella the reason why.