Scarlet finally committed herself to her boyfriend, Cole, only to have him announce he's moving away. Devastated, Scarlet turns to an old friend, Jake, and a one-night stand leaves her alone with a pregnancy test. Two years later, she's engaged to Jake with everyone thinking he's the father of her child, but it's not true. Suddenly, Cole and his family returns, but Scarlet has fallen in love with Jake and doesn't want to leave him. With both boys fighting for her, who will she choose?