Four women, born in four different decades, come together once a month at the little red brick church on Washington Street for The First Saturday K.L.U.M.S.I.E.E. Crafter's Club --a time they dedicate to creativity, decadent food, and sharing the happenings of their lives. Over the years, they've learned most everything about one another, but each keeps a a single dark secret from the others. When a new pastor arrives they warn him to beware of the church's ghost, but when history threatens to repeat, belief in a local legend becomes full fledged terror of a vengeful spirit. As each woman's story is revealed, the ties that bind the families of the small town become more tangled and entwined until past and present blur into a stunning moment of revelation.