Audrey Sanchez is unlucky in love. She's never been kissed, never been on a date, never had a boyfriend, and when the man of her dreams turns her down for her cousin, she decides to swear off love permanently. That is, until she's chosen to play Juliet in her theater company's upcoming version of Romeo and Juliet for the Shakespeare Festival. Things get especially interesting when the company takes a trip to Verona and Audrey makes a wish that will change her life forever. Suddenly she is sought out by the men of Shakespeare, each professing their love for her. It's hard enough to swear off love in one of the most romantic cities in the world, but it's even harder when history's most romantic men are after you.