In every girl's life, there is that one boy that changes everything. That one boy that makes food taste better, music sound better, and reality seem like a fairytale. For Scarlet Caraway, that one boy was Nate. That was until he moved all the way across the world. Now, it's been two years and their love for each other has faded away...or so she thought. Scarlet has moved on with a new boyfriend, new friends, and a new whole. Everything was going perfect until that one day where Nate shows up unexpectedly at her front door. Now, Scarlet was choose who her heart really belongs to. Her once loved boyfriend, Nate, or her jocky new boyfriend- Ben. Who will she choose? And more importantly, how far will the boys go to get Scarlet's heart?