Select All
  • That Smiling Idiot (Jeff the killer x reader)
    482K 14.6K 62

    Y/n is a popular serial killer with the catch phrase 'close your eyes and say goodbye', when she take the throne of most popular serial killer Jeff hunts her down. Will their rivalry turn into love? Or will they continue to try and kill each other? Highest ranks I've ever been: #1 creepypasta #1 jeffthekillerxreader...

  • Cruel & Blue (Eyeless Jack story)
    2.1M 75.6K 77

    [SEQUEL to Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story)] In the quaint town of Gracewood, Virginia, Ao Matsukochi lives comfortably with her adoptive parents and her loyal friends. For her, everyday is full of practice and optimism. Though, every person has their quirks. Sam is her best friend, who also happens to be in...

    Completed  
  • Wide Eyes (Jeff the Killer Romance)
    530K 16.3K 25

    A young woman has the displeasure of meeting Jeff the Killer when he tries to murder her. Everyone has an adam's apple.

    Completed  
  • Never Go To Sleep (Jeff the Killer romance)
    741K 31.8K 38

    Maya's just a normal girl. Unfortunately, she is the only girl to have escaped Jeff the Killer. When she escapes she thinks it's over, but she has no idea that this is just the beginning of her love-filled nightmare.

  • Blind Date (Jeff the killer romance)
    43.4K 1.9K 27

    She's blind,she's suicidal,and in the eyes for one of the most famous killers also known as Jeff the Killer.She's 17 and has flaws like a scar over her eyes and self-inflected scars but what drives her to Jeff is her hate for life it self,and her love for blood on her tongue. Read to find out more..................

  • My Savior (Ticci Toby X Reader)
    671K 22.1K 81

    You had an abusive family. No one cared for you nor your little sister, Cherokee. She meant everything to you. She was your life. Your guys bond was like no other. Until someone breaking into your house and taking away. This stranger saved you and fell in love with you..

  • A Killer Life( Creepypasta x Reader)
    430K 10K 32

    Y/n is just a average girl with loving parents and a great life, so what happens when one little event changes her whole life.

    Completed  
  • Creepypasta boyfriend scenarios
    5.1M 73.5K 97

    Noone seems to have done this... so I thought i would :D AND these ARE mine, they're just from my Quotev account, so no i am not stealing these and you cant take them either! ANYWAY! LETS BEGIN

  • The time has come( Masky love story)
    9 0 1

    This is a creepypasta story. It's about a abused girl trying to protect her brother only to witness him being killed in front of her very eyes. What she spent kno is that she has a power within her that bursts out as soon as she witnesses her brothers death. During the story she will encounter the proxy and the rest o...

  • Jeff The Killer: My Dad is a Killer
    11.4K 292 27

    Lilac is now a teenager and she is a honors student. She wants to experience love and risks herself into doing things that can cause her to get into big trouble. Will she tell someone like her closest friend or her "crush" that her dad is a killer? This is Lilacs life...

    Completed  
  • Ticci toby x masky.
    23.3K 411 29

    Toby and masky were quiet for the first month, but that changed win they saw the first proxy kate. Masky go's back and forth with toby and kate and then lying got tossed into the mix, lying as in kate saying she has tobys babys and for the longest time. One day toby was unhappy finding out kate was lying and asky went...

    Completed  
  • A Game Worth Playing (BENdrowned x Reader)
    256K 6.9K 41

    Sorry if it sucks, its my first story... (I do NOT own any of the pics or creepypastas in this story)

    Completed  
  • Killer love (A Jeff The Killer romance.)
    56.4K 2K 27

    Hello, my names Katie, and I'm in love with a serial killer. I don't know if he likes me or wants to kill me. It took me a while to figure out I was in love with him. I doubted my love for him because well... He kills people! And why would I fall for a person who kills people! But I can't help but flush and get b...