Animal Club (Yandere Boys x Reader story)

Chapter 2: Bare skin

How long have I been hiding in my room? It feels like hours. And why am I here? Because there is a naked man outside in the hall and I can't call for help because my cellphone is in the kitchen. As I am contemplating my own stupidity there was is a small scratching at the door and a tiny voice calls out.

"Please let me in."
"Who are you?" I yell at him. "How did you get in here? And why are you naked!?"

"I DON'T KNOW!" The guys voice cries out pitifully. Surprisingly he sounds very upset and fearful as his voice wavers on hysteria. It draws on my protective nature as I edge forward. I creak open the door and peer outside and the guy is still sitting on the floor in a little lump looking around. The guy appears to be about my age. He is lightly tanned with avast array of brownish spots and freckles all over his arms and face. His hair is an unruly mass of brown and his eyes appear brown at first glance but the more I looked at them the more orange they became in color. He sees me looking at him and gasps before pulling the blanket up over his head and burying his face in the covers.

"DON'T LOOK AT ME!" He begs as his whole body seems to shake.

"Why? Because you are naked?"
"naked?" He asks me confused. He then looks down under the covers, see's his body, and panics as he grabs his leg from under the covers and pulls it out into the open, completely revealing himself. "WHAT IS THIS THING!?" He screams. As I shield my eyes the guy starts to hyperventilate. "WHAT IS HAPPENING!?"

"Please calm down." I beg him and just then I hear other noises coming from the kitchen.

"Dad?" I call out as I look between the kitchen and the naked guy on the floor. I've sort of lowered my guard since the guy doesn't seem particularly dangerous. I can hear the birds in the kitchen going absolutely berserk so I'm kind of worried its another intruder.

"Are you alone?" I ask the freckled boy.
"Aren't we all?" Was his solemn reply as he clutched the blankets to his neck and breathed in deep long breathes. I pushed him aside and he toppled over like a bag of rags as I walked to the kitchen. Inside there was yet another nude man. This one was much taller with long black hair and pale pink  skin and he was currently raiding our kitchen fridge.

"HEY!" I yelled at him, before realizing that maybe that wasn't such a great idea. The man turned to me and he had the biggest black eyes I had ever seen. He stared at me for a second, completely unfazed and then went straight back to eating out of the fridge. By this point the freckled boy had followed me by dragging himself along the floor with his hands. When he reached my feet he collapsed, exhausted and then reached out a hand to me as if he was expecting something.
"What is it?" I asked him and he looked up at me while still remaining withdrawn in the covers.

"...my reward." He stated blankly.

"Reward for what?"
"I went down the hall. I always get a reward for going down the hall. Its a long way after all."

Our hall wasn't very long. You could walk the whole thing in probably about ten steps. I looked down at him confused as I tried to figure out what he was talking about when I thought hit me. Those eyes...they were not normal. Those round orange eyes of his were so unnatural yet at the same time so familiar that I was suddenly struck with a thought.

"Wait here." I told him as I ran back to my room and grabbed a turtle treat from next to the tank, a small ball or dehydrated shrimp that probably tasted terrible to humans. I then slowly walked back down the hall and placed it in the boys hands. He took one look at it and immediately retreated into the covers as I could hear him munching on it. When he withdrew again it was gone and I could see him chewing.

"It usually lasts longer than that." The guy muttered seemingly unfulfilled.

"That can't be right." I muttered to myself. "This can't be happening." I ran a shaking hand through my hair and then pointed down at him. "You're a turtle?"

"Yes."

"You're Sheldon?"

"Yes."

"Then who is that?" I pointed at the tall guy who was still raiding the fridge.
"Dont know." Was his reply as I left him to steadily walk closer to the other guy. As I walked I passed the rat cage and looked in to see it empty and the door open. I walked up to the guy and tapped him on the shoulder. He looked down at me, seemingly uninterested in my presence.

"Are you...the rat?" I asked and he stared at me as he chewed on whatever weird assortment of food he had in his mouth. I expected to him to say something but he didn't and instead just went back to the food. I hadn't received an answer but I could kind of tell in a glance what was happening as I surveyed the room. Besides from the two boys the rest of the animals were the same. The birds were in their cage eating seed and the lizard was basking in its heat lamp. I took several deep breathes as I tried to pull together what remaining sanity I had left before turning to the boys who were still stark naked.

"I can kind of guess what's happening." I said to them and they both looked at me with odd expressions. "Ill try to figure out why this has happened but in the meantime please put on some clothes." Just then my phone ringed and I grabbed it thinking it was my dad but instead it was my elderly neighbor who lived next door.

"I hate to be a bother." Were her first words through the phone.
"Can I call you back later?" I asked her as I kept looking back at the guys.

"I just wanted to call to tell you that there's a naked man in your pool."