You/Melissa Benoist/Katie McGrath

839 25 16

Summary: You're a season regular

AN: Will be posting prompts at this hour from now on as I'm starting school soon and adjusting to my new schedule. Whatever anyone says. Don't get any 8:00AM classes. You'll die. 

Suggested by: Rexburn12

You headed to the usual bar that you sang during the weekends. It was the only thing that you did as a hobby since you were always working. You worked two jobs to be able to afford your apartment and be able to afford your classes. It helped pass the time and you did it for fun. You never expected for anything to come out of it.

You began singing your favorite song 'Never Too Late' by Three Days Grace, when you noticed them looking over at you. During your entire year of coming up on stage and singing in front of several crowds, you had never gotten nervous. Seeing them look at you with that particular spark in their eye, made you nervous. No one ever looked at you.

As soon as you finished the song, you rushed to the little room they gave you to change and headed outside to your car. You wanted to forget about them and cursed as you forgot your purse inside. You were making your way back when you spotted them coming out of the bar. 

"Wait, we just want to talk to you. I'm Melissa and this is Katie. We heard your singing inside and just fell in love with your voice."

Katie waived at you when Melissa introduced her to you.

"I'm not sure if you've heard of us but we're from a TV show called Supergirl. Have you heard of it?"

You shook your head. You worked two jobs and was a full time student as well. You hardly had time to watch tv.

"We would love for you to join us. We've been looking for someone with a killer voice for an episode and you're it. The job is yours if you want it."

"Listen, I would love to but I don't have time to film an episode. I'm quite busy. I have two jobs and lots of classes to go to."

Seeing that they were losing you, they had to do something.

"The pay for episode will be around 20,000."

She said out loud. This intrigued you as it what you would earn in a year for one of your jobs. It'll let you quit one so you could have some time to relax. 

"I'll do it then."

"Great. Come to this address tomorrow morning so you can do the paperwork for the role. We're looking forward to working with you."

True to her word, you had gotten paid 20,000 for the role. You were thankful for them casting you  as it helped you deal with your loans. 

Melissa and Katie spent the entire week hanging out with you. Inviting you out for lunch and making sure to make you feel included. You didn't think anything of it as you thought they were being friendly. You never noticed how they would always randomly try to touch you, hug you a little longer than others and little things like that.

It was your last day of filming and you were pulled in for a meeting that you weren't sure what it was about.

"We'd like to offer you a deal to be this season's recurring character. The fans loved you and your chemistry with Melissa and Katie. We think it'll boost the views for the show. We'll give you your own trailer and increase your pay. We were also told that you're also a student so we can work around your schedule. We'll only film your scenes when you don't have any scenes to film."

As they continued talking, you kept growing much more excited. This was just perfect you. You were exhausted from your jobs and this was just a perfect opportunity. You quickly signed and headed out to celebrate with Katie and Melissa. You were going to invite the others to tell them the good news but they had insisted it was just going to be special for you.

You knocked on Katie's door and patiently waited for them to open up.

Katie opened the door and led you to the dining room where Melissa was already waiting. She stood up to hug you and give you a kiss on the cheek just as Katie had done. 

The three of you ate dinner while talking about the week you had until eventually nothing was left on anyone's plate. 

Melissa cleared her throat and pushed her plate aside as she turned to face you.

"We had ulterior motives when we invited you here."

Katie nods and joins Melissa.

"We did."

They both took a deep breath and at the same time said 'We're dating.'

You raised your eyebrow at them. You never liked to be in anyone's business

"I'm happy for the two of you."

"We're also both really into you."

Okay, so maybe this was your business. You cleared your throat and looked at the two of them.

"The two of you are very beautiful and smart but I don't think I'm one for relationships. I'm so busy all the time and I'm sure three will be a crowd.

"Just go with us on a date. We'll show you that it won't. If you think it's not for you or that three's a crowd then we'll just continue being friends."

You smiled at their suggestion and nodded.

"Okay, a date it is then."


Send me prompts and suggestions. Will do any female celebrity or character.

I have several prompts to do and will post them in this order

Lena Luthor - Part 2

Chloe Decker

Lena Luthor

Lena Luthor

Piper Perabo

Morgana Pendragon


Sorry for the long wait. Will try to post them as soon as I can.

Thank you!

You/Katie Mcgrath and others ImaginesWhere stories live. Discover now