Dead Again - Jeff The Killer x Reader

Return

*Another trigger warning ⚠️*

Kill yourself for him.

No.

No, I can't do that.

Why not?

Because if I kill myself, then-

Then-

Then what?

Who's going to play Minecraft with BEN?

Or play board games with Toby?

Or annoy Slender?

There won't be anyone who can take my place.

And most importantly, who would keep Jeff in line?

If I died, he'd go full psycho and probably kill everyone he sees.

I can't let people suffer like that.

Slender will kill you if you don't start killing.

But I can't die-

"You seem to forget that if there's nothing left of you, there's nothing to reawaken."

I gulped, knowing this was my last chance.

If I wanted to live, I'd have to become what they are.

A ruthless killer.

Do you even have the guts to be a killer?

I don't know.

Slender said that as soon as you stepped through the mansion doors, you were insane.

But is that really true for me?

I guess you'll have to find out~

Yeah, maybe you're right.

"Jeff?" I asked, wiping the tears from my eyes.

He put his knife away and quickly scrambled off of the boys body.

He stood up and reached his hand out carefully.

"(Y/N), I'm so sorry, you weren't supposed to see that, I-" I cut him off.

"It's okay, I want to try it." I said quietly.

"You- you what?" He asked.

"I want to try killing someone." I said it louder.

He paused, staring at me.

A huge, real grin spread across his face, even his cut smile couldn't hide it.

I couldn't help but smile too.

Seeing him so happy, it makes me happy.

"Like, tonight?" He asked, taking both my hands in his.

I nodded.

He dropped my hands and instead put his hands on my cheeks, giving me a passionate kiss.

"I love you." He whispered, breaking the kiss.

My eyes widened and I smiled again.

"You gonna say it back?" He asked.

"Nope." I popped the 'p'.

"You bitch." He said.

"Okay asshole, you wanna start that shit? Cause I can start that shit." I asked.

"I was just kidding, chill. But seriously you are a bitch. B-But I love it!" He said quickly.

"You're mean." I huffed.