You/Kara Danvers/Lena Luthor

878 32 10

Summary: Lena and Kara like you

AN: Suggested by: JennyHoneyBunny

You had first met Kara Danvers at the coffee shop that she frequented while she had first been an assistant to Cat Grant. She was actually the one that had come up to you and introduced herself. It was quite nice of her considering that you were new and knew no one in the city.

Lena had been the second person you had met after Kara. Kara had actually been the one that had introduced you to her. She had forgotten that she had scheduled lunch with you and Lena. You didn't mind and even offered to have lunch at another time but she insisted on you coming with her and meeting Lena.

You had developed a crush on both of your new friends. Kara and Lena were both sweet, beautiful and smart. They were everything you looked for when went out on the date. It especially helped that Lena seemed the type of person who would bend you over her desk while Kara seemed to be the one you would love to bend over a desk. Kara could possibly even bend you over the desk but you were still iffy on that whole theory. Either way, you didn't seem to mind either possibilities. You kept this to yourself as you knew your new friendships would be destroyed if they found out about your crushes on them. It wasn't even a crush, you knew you really liked them.

Kara had developed a small crush on (y/n) since meeting her at Noonan's. It was in fact the whole reason why she even worked up the courage to walk up to your table and talk to you. Each day she spent with you, her crush on you got bigger. It's been a couple of weeks and Kara had still been trying to work up the courage to ask you out on a date. Each time she did, she would end up chickening out and simply asking you out on a friend date. It was getting annoying.

Lena knew the moment she had first seen you with Kara that she had to have you. You were beautiful and as she got to know you, it made her fall a little more in love. She never mentioned her crush to Kara as she didn't want to freak her out. Sure, Kara had a lesbian sister but it was still quite scary coming out to someone. Lena hadn't had the chance to ask you out on a date as she would tend to be quite busy and wouldn't have the time to go out on a date with you. She wanted to wait until she was sure that she wouldn't cancel as she didn't want to upset you.

A week later and both Lena and Kara had decided today would be the day to ask you out. Lena was no longer busy and Kara finally worked out the courage to ask you out on a date. The two of them dressed up, picked up your favorite flowers and headed towards your apartment. Neither of them had expected to find the other at your apartment lobby.

"What are you doing?"

"What are you doing?"

Lena held up her hand and motioned to the flowers.

"What does it look like I'm doing. I came here to ask out (y/n) on a date?"

"You?! You didn't tell me you were into girls?"

Kara asked surprised.

"Neither did you."

"Fair point."

Lena started walking towards the elevator but was soon stopped by Kara standing in front of her.

"Move Kara."

"No. I get first dibs on asking her out on a date. I introduced her to you. You can't just do that."

Lena raised her eyebrow at Kara's words.

"Dibs? Kara, we're not in high school. We're both adults here."

"I don't care. I'm asking her out on a date and you can't stop me."

Kara rushed to get on the elevator and quickly pressed the button to your floor. Lena cursed her out and took off her heels to run up the stairs. The two arrived at the same time.

"It seems like neither of us is going to back off. We need to deal with this. I don't want to ruin our friendship because we both like the same woman."

Kara nodded in agreement. Lena was her best friend, she wasn't about to lose her over something like this.

"We both ask her out at the same time. Whoever she choose, the other agrees to stay away from the relationship and won't pursue to try to date her."

"That's fair. What about if she picks both of us?"

Lena hadn't even thought of that. Was it possible for you to pick both of them.

"We'll deal with that when it happens. Let's ask her out and see who she picks."

The two of them walked over to your door and knocked on your door.

"Kara? Lena? I wasn't expecting you guys."

They handed you their flowers before Lena explained what was going on.

"We both wanted to ask you out on a date. We found out that we both liked you and couldn't get the other to back off so we figured we would give you the choice. We'll 100% respect your choice and have agreed that the person she doesn't choose will back off."

You waited a while to answer.


"Yes? Yes to what? Yes to Lena or Yes to me?"

Lena turned around to face Kara, giving her a look that made her realize what she meant.

"Oh! You mean the two of us?"


Send me prompts and suggestions. Will do any female celebrity or character.

I have several prompts to do and will post them in this order

Kara Danvers - Part 2

Morgana Pendragon

Kara Danvers

Morgana Pendragon - Part 2

Sorry for the long wait. Will try to post them as soon as I can.

Thank you!

You/Katie Mcgrath and others ImaginesWhere stories live. Discover now