Mikey~ Difficult Decisions

213 8 4

Before I start, I have a friend who just started a tmnt x reader. You guys should check it out:)  


After the meeting, Percy and Annabeth invited you both to Cabin Three. Mikey still seemed to be in awe of the camp and the fact that he got to meet his favorite book characters. Jason passed by a waved at your small group, earning greetings from everyone... except Mikey.

Mikey grumbled under his breath. "He's not one of my favorites anymore."

You giggle silently so Percabeth wouldn't hear. "Why? What did Jason do to you?"

"He caught you in his arms as if he couldn't have just used his wind powers to catch you." He folded his arms. "The only person that gets to carry my girlfriend like that is me!"

You smiled at your boyfriend's jealousy. "Oh, come on, Mikey. You know he didn't mean it like that. He has Piper, remember?"

"Yeah, but I'm still watching him." What he said next you didn't hear. "Might throw another brick at his head." (#Brason forever)

You noticed that a lot of campers stopped what they were doing and were staring at you and Mikey. You looked down at your clothes and shoes, trying to figure out what they could possibly be looking at.

"Is there something on my face?" You asked Annabeth.

She laughed lightly as she turned around to look at you, but her smile quickly fell when her eyes landed on you, or more so above you. He grabbed Percy and pointed above your head. You panicked and turned to look at Mikey, but your mouth fell agape when you saw the symbol of Hermes hovering above his head.

 You panicked and turned to look at Mikey, but your mouth fell agape when you saw the symbol of Hermes hovering above his head

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

"Dudette, you were just claimed by Poseidon!" Mikey gasped as he threw his hands into the air.

"Mikey, you were just claimed by Hermes!" you said in shock, but then with a little less shock in your voice said, "That actually makes a lot of sense

Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.

"Mikey, you were just claimed by Hermes!" you said in shock, but then with a little less shock in your voice said, "That actually makes a lot of sense."

You grew slightly nervous. The Big Three (Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon) weren't supposed to have kids, with the exception of Percy, Jason, Nico, Hazel, and Thalia. After thinking about it, all three of them lowkey sucked at keeping their promises to not have any demigod children. However, what you couldn't understand was why were you a child of Poseidon in this world? 

"There's no way that this can end well." You face palmed.

Percy put his arms around your shoulder and practically fangirled over your existence. "I can't believe I have another sibling! Tyson would be so excited right now!"

~~~~~Time skip brought to you by Blackjack the Pegasus~~~~~

Unlike my other stories, I'm going to make this scene up instead of putting you guys into a scene from the fandom.

The next day at breakfast, Mikey seemed to fit in with his new "siblings" just fine. He and Connor Stoll were planning countless pranks to do throughout the week. 

You and Percy got along well. You laughed at his sassiness and all of his dumb remarks. Today, though, you couldn't shake the feelings that something was going to go wrong. Percy easily picked up on your mood change.

"(Y/N), you good? Need some more blue pancakes?" He smiled softly and pushed his stack of pancakes towards you.

You laughed a little as you shook your head. "I just feel like something is about to happen."

"Did you have one of those demigod dreams last night?" He asked.

"No, I just have a gut feeling killing me. Like any minute now somethings going to-"

Before you could finish your sentence the ground rumbled slightly under your feet.

"-attack." You sighed.

Monsters slammed against the force field surrounding the camp. All the campers ran to get their weaponry and supplies for battle. You retrieved your (weapon) from Cabin Three. You noticed that it was now made out of celestial bronze.  Mikey ran up to you with his chucks, which were also different now. 

"Dudette, this can't be good. It's like we brought danger with us when we fell out of the sky!" He screamed over the sounds of the battle.

The two of you ran through the camp's border alongside Percy and Annabeth. "I know. Just stay safe out there, baby." You kissed his cheek and attacked an empousa (a female monster with multiple feet of a donkey, bronze, an ox, goat, or a human).

Percy grinned at the sight of the Minotaur running awkwardly hunched over to one side because of the weight of his one remaining horn. "Don't worry, bud. I'll cut the other one off to even you out a bit."

After fighting for what felt like hours, the monsters kept coming. The Apollo cabin was working diligently to care for everyone's wounds, but the number of injuries kept growing. The three fates appeared in the distance with two strings shared between them.

"Send us (Y/N) and Michelangelo and this will all stop." They chorused in unison.

You and Mikey looked at each other, fear evident on both of your faces. Percy and Connor stepped in front of both of you as the Fates continued to advance towards you.

"They do not belong here. They must die to restore order." One of the Fates snapped their fingers and to giants formed from the ground. 

"Mikey..." You didn't finish your sentence, but Mikey understood.

He nodded back to you before stepping forward towards the Fates. "Will everyone else be spared?" The three fates nodded and held their scissors up to the two pieces of thread. "Then we surrender."

Mikey kissed you one last time. "I love you, Skater Girl. More than anything."

"I love you, too,  my pizza loving boyfriend."

And with that, the two giants grabbed you and threw you into their mouths just as everything went black.


Wow a sucky ending, by a sucky author... Nice. 

TMNT x Reader ScenariosRead this story for FREE!