Eli almost never had sex with girls. Even though he was bisexual, he favored men more than he did women, which was why he only ever had boyfriends, never girlfriends. Sounds weird, but that's how he rolled. I asked him about it one day and he brushed me off, so I never brought it up again.
Eli and I were never physically sexual with each other. We tossed some words here and there, what we could offer to each other as a joke, and sometimes he would pull my hair and such, but that day was the first time he had ever touched me in that manner and I was craving his touch again. I was always sexually attracted to Eli ever since I first laid eyes on him, five years ago, when I was nineteen.
Then he made out with a guy and I knew I had no chance. He might as well be fully gay from the way he views things. But, Eli is Eli and there is no changing him.
"So, you're telling me that your best friend, Eli Minorelli, owner of that club everyone talks about, basically gay, was sexual with you?" Mellie, my girl best friend asked, pointing her fork at me. I rolled my eyes towards the ceiling before looking at her again. Her golden brown skin glowed in the lighting of the cafe, her long curly hair up in a bun for her job interview later.
"Yes! And he wasn't just...sexual. He was demanding, and-and-"
"Dominant?" Mellie offered.
"Yes! Oh my god, he put his hand around my throat and I almost died with happiness." I slumped back, a goofy smile on my face...until I realized I had never told Eli I liked that before. "Wait, how did he know I liked being choked?" She shrugged and took a bite out of her western omelet.
"Maybe he likes choking people, I don't know. I'm not into that shit, but I'm not judging." I smiled and started eating my muffin, pondering this. There was no way he could've known this, unless, like Mellie said, he was into stuff like that also. I brushed my blonde hair out of my face and opened my mouth to speak, when the door of the cafe opened. Two men entered and I frowned.
"Eli?" I questioned, watching as my best friend walked in, another man trailing behind him. His eyes flitted to our table and he raised an eyebrow before walking over. This was the first time I'd seen him since our little incident a few days ago and the memories of his fingers inside me made my cheeks burn.
"What's up?" he asked, sliding into the booth beside me. He threw his arm behind me, resting it there. The man that was with him stood, looking a bit hesitant. Eli pressed a kiss to my temple and I sighed, smiling. His kiss meant everything between us was okay.
"What are you doing here? You usually go straight to work." I commented and he shrugged, taking off his jacket. His muscles bunched together and my eyes trailed down the expanse of his back, liking what I saw. A kick from across the table connected with my shin and I glared at Mellie, who was giving me a look. She noticed how I was staring at Eli.
"I stumbled upon an old friend and decided to take him out." Eli answered, finally looking over at the man. He furrowed his brows when he realized the man was still standing. "Sit." he ordered and my eyes widened at how the man instantly obeyed.
"Where's James?" I wondered, taking a sip of my drink.
"You fucked him, remember? Or did you forget that I was in the room when you came around his cock like a bitch in heat?" Eli answered and I choked on the water I was drinking, which turned into a coughing fit. Mellie's eyes widened at what Eli said.
"Alice, you slept with his boyfriend?" she asked, but I couldn't answer her since I was too busy dying. Eli rubbed my back, and bit his lip, trying to hold back laughter. I shot him a look that could kill, but he wasn't fazed.
"Yeah, she did and I walked right in when they finally jumped off the sexual cliff." he explained and Mellie snorted with laughter. I felt my cheeks heat up and I just wanted to disappear. Usually, I wasn't fazed by stuff like this, but to orgasm right when your best friend catches you in the act with his boyfriend is pretty embarrassing.
"Okay, okay. I'm pretty sure we all have work we need to go to, so move it." I said, pushing Eli so that he could move out the way. His man friend, who still hadn't said a word this entire time got out the booth so that Eli could get out. "I gotta go to the bathroom real quick, but I'll be back soon and then we can leave." I said to Mellie and she nodded before I took off.
When I got to the bathroom, I went straight to the mirror to check myself out. I had my blonde bob in waves, framing my face nicely. My white blouse was unbuttoned at the top, to show a hint of cleavage and my skirt was long enough to be appropriate for work. The black heels I was wearing was perfect for showing off my long legs. I turned around to check out my ass, which was pretty nice if I do say so myself.
Just then, the door opened and Eli walked in, raising an eyebrow. His eyes travelled down my body, and a small smile appeared on his face. "You have a nice ass." he complimented and I looked in the mirror.
"Oh, I know, trust me. Now, what are you do-Eli?" I started backing up when he stalked forward, gazing at something on my neck. When my back hit the wall, I started walking forward, but he was already in front of me, pushing me back.
"Hm. He marked you." he said quietly, softly tracing what I figured to be a hickey from James. I'd seen it this morning, but I didn't think it was bad enough for me to cover it up. "Maybe I should mark you." I placed my hands on Eli's chest to push him away, but for some reason, they just stayed put.
"What the hell has gotten into you, E? I fuck your boyfriend and suddenly, you have some type of sexual interest in me?" I asked, getting frustrated. His close proximity was doing nothing to help my hormones and the feel of his chest beneath my fingers was doing something to my head.
He chuckled deeply, putting his forehead on mine. His dimples, which usually appeared when he was laughing, surfaced for a bit. "Oh, honey. I've always been sexually interested in you. I just never had a reason to act on it, until now." I shivered as he traced the column of my neck, my breathing becoming a bit haggard.
"I thought you didn't care for girls." I whispered, gulping when his lips pressed against my throat.
"I'm bisexual, not gay. I can change my mind whenever I want to." he responded. With that, he pulled some of my skin into his mouth and started sucking on it viciously. I gasped as prickles of pain shot through me, turning into pleasure when he laved it away with his tongue.
My hands reached up and grabbed a fistful of his hair, tugging harshly. He made a sound in the back of his throat and snuck an arm around my waist. He lifted his head and looked at me through hooded eyes before attacking my lips. I pressed my body up against his and he reached around me, grabbing a handful of my ass.
Eli lifted me up and I wrapped my legs around his waist, groaning into his mouth when he thrusted his hips into me. I reached down to unbuckle his belt, but his hand stopped me midway. I pulled away from him, my breath coming out in pants.
"What?" I asked, wondering what was wrong. He pulled away, closing his blue eyes for a second, his swollen lip plump from our escapade.
"I'm not having sex with you." Eli said, licking his lips and backing away. I frowned and slid off the counter, adjusting my skirt and shirt.
"Why the hell not? If it's because of James, then you need to-"
"It's not that. And fuck James." he paused. "Oh wait, never mind, you did."
"Eli, stop." I snapped, reaching out for him. He held his hand up to stop me and I let my hand drop. "Why won't you have sex with me?" I asked and he sighed.
"Well, then un-complicate it." Eli ignored me and looked at his watch.
"We need to go. The other two are probably wondering what happened to us." he said, gesturing for me to leave first. I walked towards the door and pulled it open before looking over my shoulder.
"I like a challenge." I stated and then walked out, fluffing my hair as I went.
Like a bitch in heat ;)
YOU ARE READING
The Dom Inside MeParanormal
(Book 1) "You wanna know how I know you're not sorry?" he whispered. "How?" I asked quietly. In a flash, he pulled me against him and drove his fingers inside me, eliciting a loud gasp from my lips. "Because when you came, you looked straight in my...