Try Again (I_Am_Wildcat x Reader)

13

A/N: I just realized it's been a super long time since I updated this!! AND I LEFT IT ON A CLIFFHANGER! I'm so sorry guys! I hope you don't hate me! Thanks for almost 500 reads :) I never even thought I'd get 10!

What are you guys thinking of this story anyways? Don't forget to leave me a comment and maybe vote? Thanks :)

As always, 

~I_Aint_Weldkat

~~~

I stared at the beautiful ring meant for me in my hand and my heart was flooded with so much emotion. He was actually going to propose to me.

"Tyler... I..."

"You don't have to say anything," he croaked, "That was stupid too, I'm sorry. I shouldn't have shown you that."

I didn't know what to say. I wanted him to know it was okay that he showed me, but I knew it wasn't. It just made things more difficult, because I knew that I wanted to say yes, but there was so much to think about.

"I don't know what to do," I whispered, frozen in place.

He sat next to me on the bed and took my hand in his, "Go back to your room. Forget this happened and be happy." He caressed my cheek, "I just want you to be happy." He leaned in and lightly pressed his lips to mine before pulling back, "We'll talk more back in Indiana."

I looked into his eyes for a little bit longer before standing up and sitting the little box on the nightstand. Then I left him and started walking back to my room. I couldn't comprehend what had just happened. I turned a corner and leaned against the wall, trying to catch my breath.

I made myself breath in and out because I could feel myself starting to have a panic attack. I had to convince myself that I was okay and that everything was okay, which was hard because it wasn't.

I didn't deserve Tyler. He was too good for me.

Once I finally got a hold of myself I went back to my room like he told me to, where I found Brian lounging on one of the beds.

My extra key card was resting on the night stand. I must've left it down at the pool.

I sighed and moved a few strands of hair from my face. I could still feel Tyler's touch on my skin as Brian spoke.

"You forgot your key down at the pool," he told me. "Where've you been?" There was no hint of accusation in his question, it was merely just curiosity.

"I was... talking to Tyler," I said nervously.

"'Bout what?"

I sat down on the edge of the bed, "Me and him."

I think he caught onto my tone because he sat up and looked at me with more concentration, "And?"

"And I think I'm going to take him back."

"But what about me?"

"What about you?" I asked, "You're my friend. You've always been my friend."

He looked down and sighed, "I hope this doesn't change anything between us, then."

"It won't," I assured him, "As long as you let it go."

"I will," he nodded, "Friends it is." He stood up. "I guess I'll see you tomorrow."

"Yeah, PAX day," I stopped him as he reached the door, "Oh, Brian?"

He turned back around, "Yeah?"

"When you kissed me, did you know Tyler was watching?"

He froze up but didn't respond.

"I thought so." I stated, standing up and turning to him, "That was a really bitchy thing to do."

"I'm sorry..." he said quietly.

"Yeah, I bet you are." That was the last thing I had to say to him before he left.

I layed back down on my bed and let out a breath of air. Now all I had to do was figure out how to get Tyler back.