Cheat On Me Once Shame On You, Cheat On Me Twice Fuck You

Chapter 2- Can We Pretend That We're Good?

"Stop talking," he says to Kinsley

"Kinsley she says you've 72 hours for you to move out, I need you to move out within the next 24 hours," he says to her. "I need to fix things with her".

Back at Vinnie's apartment in the middle of the night he hears a loud banging on their door and sees his crying, little sister."

"Paisley, what happened?" he asks his fragile sister.

"He lied," she said, crying.

"Mi hermana" hugging his sister. Letting her into the house.

Drew looked for Paisley that exact night after she yelled at him that morning and all he could guess was she was at her brothers' place so he pulled up to his place and knocked on the door.

"Oh fuck off" as Vinnie try to closed the door "Let me talk to her" he says to him

"She's sleep, please comeback in the morning, estúpido." he says to him

"Dude, we made pack" talking to Vinnie

"Dude, you broke my little sisters' heart."

"I know but I need to talk to her" demanding to be let in. "Baby, who's at the door?" Gracie asks Vinnie

"He's about to leave."

"Bro, let me talk to her" pushing on the door

"Drew" Gracie says

"Gracie" looking at her 6 month old pregnant sister.

"Why are you here?" she asks him

"I need to talk to Paisley but your boyfriend won't let me talk to her".

"Vin, let him in," she tells Vinnie.

"Ok, baby".

"You've 30 minutes to explain why my little sister is here crying? He asks Drew

"I fucked up" he says

"How so Drew?"

"I slept with Kinsley last night on our birthday which falls on our anniversary being next week so she smashed everything in the apartment and even burned some things.

She made Kinsley move out because we were letting her stay there which was a mistake in the first place.

" Paisley was laying down on the couch listening to Can We Pretend That Were Good? On repeat playing through her AirPods while she was sleeping.

"Bro, that was a mistake to let her friend since birth live with y'all and to bring this up she went back to drinking again so to you she relapsed lucky she hasn't gone back to drug thank goodness and she went back to the most depressive state in her life because you caused her trauma for the rest of her life she trusted you with her life."

"Drew, she's my best friend and I did the same thing to her but now she has forgiven me but she can't forgive Kinsley because she was her friend since birth. You're my brother and broke my friend's heart. She's given chance after chance and you seem to screw it up every single damn time she gives you chance.

But I think this is the last time she gave you the chance to fix things she doesn't want to have to do anything with you again. So I suggest you leave before she wakes up." Gracie hears groans coming from the couch.

"What's going on?" Paisley says

"Why are you here, Starkey?" looking at him.

"Sorry" he says looking for a response from Paisley

"Every time you say sorry Starkey go back and do the same thing again and again which doesn't change anything for us and I wish we kept that cheating rule in place.