The Black Phone Preferences

who says i love you first

finney:
- he did
- you were reading to him because he absolutely adores it when you read to him
- it was late
- he was at your house sleeping over and you guys were just in your bed
- he started on your shoulder reading over you
- but as he got tired he laid down on top of you just looking up at you and admiring you
- before he fell asleep he just said it
- "y/n, i love you so much i hope you know that"
- the woman was too stunned to speak
- you just stopped reading for a second, smiled and looked down at him
- "i love you too finn"
- he kissed your cheek and fell asleep
- BEST NIGHT EVER

robin:
- he did
- him and his uncle got into a big fight
- which usually doesn't happen but when it does he always goes to your house everytime
- you feel like home to him so when he gets upset he goes to you for comfort
- he'll also go to his mom but apparently she agreed with his uncle
- well basically they got into a fight about how he's basically going to go nowhere in life because he's always getting into fights, detentions and suspended sometimes
- and it made him so upset that as soon as he got into your room
- he broke down
- that was the first time you've seen him cry, and honestly you were happy he came to you and that you could see the vulnerable side of him
- you just let him cry it out and rubbed his back telling him all the thing he's wanted to hear that he just said it to you
- "angel"
- "yes robin?"
- "i love you"
- he immediately started to kiss you, but it was a soft gentle kiss
- "i love you so much more robin"
- stayed over your house that night but called his mom before he did

bruce:
- you did
- sure you guys would always say it when you guys were younger but you stopped as soon as you guys started having feelings for each other
- so when you guys started dating you didn't say it to each other at all, it was different now because you guys would mean it in a romantic way
- well one day when you guys were at his house and you were making some cookies
- everything went perfect and the cookies were delicious
- well as you guys were just sitting and eating and talking you looked at him and just felt like you needed to say it
- "i love you bruce"
- HIS BIG CUTE SMILE
- he was so happy
- "god i missed hearing you say that, i love you too y/n"
- cutest most passionate kiss ever

vance:
- you both have been thinking about it but you did
- you guys were walking home from school together
- he had his arm around you
- you were talking about how this girl was pissing you off all day
- just being super snarky and always having an answer for what you had to say and you wanted to punch her in the face
- vance thought it was adorable and honestly hilarious how mad you were getting about it
- so he started to make fun of you for it saying how the girl wasn't worth your time and you get mad over the littlest things
- you glared at him and he moved his arm from over your shoulder and put his hands up in defense
- "i'm just saying dollface"
- you laughed and dragged him to your house by his hand
- you helped him do his homework because you wanted him at school because you loved seeing him there
- as he was leaving you felt like it was the perfect time to say it
- "vance"
- "yeah dollface?"
- "i love you"
- he had a small smile but tried to hide it
- FAILED TERRIBLY
- "i love you too dickface"
- he kissed you then left
- acted like he didn't care but all night he thought about it and smiled
- "god this girl is gonna turn me soft"

LOVED MAKING THIS
i'm trying to update everyday and post 3 chapters for you guys because i love updating
but i start school next week so daily updates will still happen but i'm not sure if it will be 3 chapters maybe 1-2!!!
make sure to vote and comment!!